When it comes to discourse, short is sweet, easy does it, and some logic goes a long way; however, sometimes a bit of finesse renders a statement beautiful. When asked by Ed Schultz on MSNBC should the democrats embrace the Occupy Wall Street crowd, our Joan Walsh—whose demeanor on the show I can only describe as elegant—said, "Yeah, I would like to see more democrats approaching, and they have to approach in a spirit of humility, really…" Then she explained, "There are a lot of people down there who feel burned. A lot of young people came out and voted for change in 2008. They didn't see change; instead, they got unbelievable debt." If Ed asked me the same question, he would have had to bleep every other word I said. Yet, the phrase, "in the spirit of humility," was calming, admirably tactful, extremely polite, and most of all, made me think.
Imagine you cross unto a parallel universe. You are standing on the sidewalk of a big city street. It looks different, but you know it is the other United States. The sky is blue, the air is clean and there is something pleasant about the people walking down the street. Some women are dressed conservatively, but most women, especially the younger ones, are showing too much skin. Strangely, the men are not ogling and there are no obscene gestures or whistles judging and annoying these exceptionally confident dames and damsels. Then, you realize that you are looking too hard and missing the obvious, may be because you are seeing it for the first time. Most of these women are smiling—not that fake ugly wide expression showing super-white teeth under glassy empty eyes. Instead, you see genuine, full facial smiles; and the then you turn philosopher: "Damn! When they smile from the heart, all women are beautiful."
You go to a library and start reading newspapers. You learn that in this United States all citizens, rich and poor, are truly equal under the law. Legal cost for both sides in any civil suit must equal. That is, a rich citizen will provide a defense of equal value for his poor opponent. Social programs such as social security and free healthcare are there only for those who otherwise cannot afford what these programs offer; those who can are financially responsible for their children and their parents. Illicit drugs and prostitution are regulated but legal. Both car and health insurance are not mandatory. Higher education is also free, although private universities still exist. In fact, the biggest in the country is the (free) American University with huge campuses in all fifty states, and the government finds jobs for all its graduates.
Then you figure it out, the key is free press—subsidized by the government in some cases to enforce the First Amendment—working for the people with militant emphasis on the betterment of social programs, education, employment and exposure of corruption everywhere. Free press, providing relevant information rather than disinformation, prevents people from voting against their interest. It also plays an essential part in shaping a tolerant culture with a proper order of priorities. The media's daily campaign against violence, mentioning every incident of rape or murder, rather than weeks at a time of airtime allocated to girl on a Spring Break lost in Aruba, resulted in the near eradication of gangs, let alone violent crime. Finally, this United States maintains her status as a sovereign country, enforces immigration laws, and defines immigration to include all nationalities, not just Mexican.
Meanwhile, you find out who killed Kennedy. You learn that Mitt Romney is acting in B-movies. Rush Limbaugh is doing time for ticket fraud. Sarah Palin and Glenn Beck are both in an insane asylum for cruelty against animals. Rick Perry uses his bowlegs as a cautionary tale in beef and vitamin D commercials. Michele Bachmann finally found her calling and works as a madam in her husband's first brothel for gays and lesbians in the Great State of Minnesota. Ann Coulter did one year in prison in the 80s for her involvement in an illegal donkey show on the outskirts of New Canaan, Connecticut. Now, she is the most famous and highest paid dominatrix in America, working out of Greenwich, Connecticut.
Then you cross back to our universe only to realize a vivid picture of the status quo. The big money is still enjoying the policy of eating the cake and having it too, otherwise known as "Let them bark." Every two years or so the political parties stage a fight, then compromise, and the Middle Class and Lower Class lose. Since Reagan took office, they lowered the taxes on the rich, raised the price of oil, and cut social programs. This recent show between the parties is about cutting social security and Medicare. The congress already cut some and will cut more. Only in a nation with corrupt media, can the Supreme Court rule that money equals free speech and the Congress's philosophy stoops to "fuck the poor" domestically and "fuck the Arabs" internationally. We need free press for a better common culture.
Now, for poetry lovers, and for those who take money seriously, here is a magnificent satire from a master of tetrameter couplets (although, here, he added a couple of triplets for emphasis), Hilaire Belloc.
Lord Lucky
Lord Lucky, by a curious fluke,
Became a most important duke.
From living in a vile Hotel
A long way east of Camberwell
He rose, in less than half an hour,
To riches, dignity and power.
It happened in the following way:—
The Real Duke went out one day
To shoot with several people, one
Of whom had never used a gun.
This gentleman (a Mr. Meyer
Of Rabley Abbey, Rutlandshire),
As he was scrambling through the brake,
Discharged his weapon by mistake,
And plugged about an ounce of lead
Piff-bang into his Grace's Head—
Who naturally fell down dead.
His heir, Lord Ugly, roared, "You Brute!
Take that to teach you how to shoot!"
Whereat he volleyed, left and right;
But being somewhat short of sight,
His right-hand Barrel only got
The second heir, Lord Poddleplot;
The while the left-hand charge (or choke)
Accounted for another bloke,
Who stood with an astounded air
Bewildered by the whole affair
—And was the third remaining heir.
After the Execution (which
Is something rare among the Rich)
Lord Lucky, while of course he needed
Some help to prove their claim, succeeded.
Thoth © 2011


Salon.com
Comments
The Occupy Wall Street movement would get the support of all media in any other country. The message of the movement is universally popular: social justice. That is, the movement should receive unanimous support. You know there is something fishy, something wrong, when the media does not give this movement its due coverage. Even worse, some media even boldly attack the movement. The social norm anywhere on earth should be to support social justice. Only uninformed people in America are averse to social justice. This is the fault of the corporation-owned media.
When the government tried to raise the retirement age in France, who went down the streets to protest? Young people. I hope our young people do not settle for a few jobs and continue the fight for ALL Americans.
: )
- thanks for this, Thoth.
I am in agreement with you on the lack of media coverage, I see people occupying nearby parks, yet nothing on our local news about it. I guess they think if they ignore them, eventually they will go away. The problem is "them"...
Thanks for your view, I wish one day....
"...the key is free press—subsidized by the government in some cases to enforce the First Amendment—"
Now you're reaching. Newspapers and news publications are disappearing at an alarming rate and some of the ones that are still in existence have a definite bias (usually to the right) thanks to their corporate owners. Conservatives hate NPR, PBS and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting; they'd like nothing better than to destroy them all. A free press subsidized by the government? I think it's more likely you'll step into that parallel universe than see this happen. Do we need a free press for a better common culture? Absolutely, but even more essential is this:
“Our liberty depends on the freedom of the press, and that cannot be limited without being lost.” Thos. Jefferson
We are losing it, slowly but surely.
(Love the Belloc poem.)
" Then, you realize that you are looking too hard and missing the obvious, may be because you are seeing it for the first time. Most of these women are smiling—not that fake ugly wide expression showing super-white teeth under glassy empty eyes. Instead, you see genuine, full facial smiles; and the then you turn philosopher: "Damn! When they smile from the heart, all women are beautiful.""
Once again, showing your general opinion of women... women who scorned you in the past maybe (?), ugly, fake women
In my alternate universe, nobody worries about miscreants being punished -- healing them and the ones they have hurt is what matters.
We all have our dreams of alternate universes. The point is that this one is hurtful and we can't go to that alternate universe to escape what e.e. cummings called manunkind.
I think Gandhi had a workable answer: “Be the change you want to see in the world.”
Thanks for reminding me.
Shit. Magnificent.
Goethe:
“Who is the happiest of men? He who values the merits of others,
And in their pleasure takes joy, even as though 'twere his own.
Not in the morning alone, not only at mid-day he charmeth;
Even at setting, the sun is still the same glorious plane”
………………………………………………………………………………..
I loved the way you introduced your alternate America with the image
of smiling women inviting us in.
Dressed as the whim hit them that day.
…………………………………………………………………………..
What you describe WILL happen. I assure you.
It will happen here & there, in pockets, for Feudalism is the wave of the future.
Maybe it was always inevitable.
Empires do not ever
not crumble.
………………………………………
It is regrettable all the violence that may happen.
But I aint doing no harm to no one, ever.
And guess what? Nobody wishes me harm.
……………………………………….
Empires crumble externally only after they disintegrate internally,
Which is what is starting to happen.
Don’t give up on America, thoth, please………
Blake: “Milton”:
“Rouze up, O Young Men of the New Age! set your foreheads against the ignorant Hirelings! For we have Hirelings in the Camp, the Court & the University, who would, if they could, for ever depress Mental & prolong Corporeal War.
Republican clown show.
especially that fucker from texas.
they make everything bigger there.
the damn fools especially!
A very thoughtful and well written post.
rated with love
I'm not sure everything you suggest would yield the results you suggest, though by and large I like them. (I might disagree with your comment about the Arabs, depending on what you meant: If you were talking about in comparison to Israel, I have issues; if you meant supporting internally repressive governments in exchange for oil and favors, I agree.)
You cannot have a democracy or even the semblance of a Democracy without absolute freedom of the press and now the entire mass media apparatus. It is cultural suicide to allow information to be controlled from within corporate board rooms whose only objective is to benefit themselves. The founding fathers of this nation who were perhaps the greatest assembly of intellectuals that history has ever known saw this quite clearly that is why the first amendment is what it is and not the fourth or the eight amendment. The second amendment was put their to safeguard the first amendment and the constitution is not a living document. I do not see any Thomas Jefferson's or Benjamin Franklins around that should be allowed to change one letter of it. These are commandments written in stone for a new religion because that is what America was intended to be, and if you are here in this country you are a true believer. Turn on your TV Set and you will see the infidel, pick up a newspaper and you will see the infidel, take a walk down Wall Street and you will see, hear, and smell the stench of the infidel. We stand on sacred ground. Ground that is sacred to what we believe in and we believe in freedom, equality, and justice. The infidels every breath offends these beliefs and it is time for a war of annihilation against the infidel.
HUGGGGGGGGGGG
It is right outside my window, I go back and forth all the time. Always good to see you.
@ Catherine Forsythe
It is so sad, and it is embarrassing that this happens in the US, but you know all about that. Thank you as always for your insight.
@ Joan E. Kaufman
Thousands of European millionaires and billionaires are making tons of money and paying their share of taxes; they make more and pay more, but at the end they are still very wealthy. Socialism Solves the problem of "dead money." If you invest, it is tax deductible; if you don't the government invests for you. Check them out at the South of Spain or the South of France or even better, Monte Carlo. They are having "real" fun. Having tons of money and paying high taxes are not mutually exclusive. Thank you so much for your informed comment and visit.
@ Buffy W
I was just saying in a comment that that is all we can do now: wish. Great to see, B, always.
@ Margaret Feike
That is the whole idea: to reach. I mean the whole idea is wishful thinking. But I sure would love to live in such a civilized world. Thank you so much for your visit and insight.
@ SheilaTGTG55
What needs change is the social norm in America, the common wisdom, the general attitude. The general motif, just like in the rest of the world, must favor social justice. Thank you, Sheila, for your thoughtful comment and visit.
@ scanner
I commented earlier on your excellent piece, and you admirably explain and inform. The people need to know all corruption and spin that takes place. Thank you ScanMan, keep up the just fight.
@ geezerchick
I like your parallel universe, too. I know many who took the initiative and "became the change," only to have others looking at them with this 'duh', or even worse judging them. Again, the culture need to change. Thank you so much, G, as always for your insight.
That too! I mean you hear all the time people calling for gender equality and freedom from patriarchy. Then you get women, not even men, judging other women and telling them how to dress, live, behave, and raise children. A civilized motto is this. Crimes against man--that is, hurting the body or livelihood of another--are punished by man, and crimes against God will be punished by God. Freedom must include sexual freedom. We cannot ask for progress and still maintain a medieval view of "morals."
Saying what I say in my posts means that I still have hope America. Yet, growing up in the State of Cool, CA, and then watching, for example, prop 19 gets defeated, gets one alienated. What happened to all the cool?
Thank you so much, my philosopher friend, for your beautiful comment.
Thanks, Matt. It is always good to see you, bubba.
@ Snowden
This is why I cannot watch the news; it is bad for my blood pressure. I heard Joan say it all, eloquently. I have so much disdain for politicians; it is hard to keep my cool. Thank you for your visit.
@ RomanticPoetess
Yeah, I know, I can only dream. Thank you so much for your gracious visit and poetic comment.
"Maybe what we really need is a seriously enlightened dictator."
Yes Sir, unfortunately, that seems to be the only solution. People cringe when they hear the word dictator, but if they stop and think for a minute about an 'enlightened dictator', they may see the light.
I read George Bernard Shaw say something like that but he did not use your phrase. I would like permission to use it!
You know my stance on Israel. I meant the 50-60 year old policy of treating Arabs like second rate humans. Whatever the Arabs may be, this policy is not in our best interest.
Enlightened dictator. To look at world governments held up to Kosher's example.. well, just to say that I wish he'd have been able to list more examples :(. But that's what has always gotten me, from the very first job I held with a manager who made everything work the way it should work - once you show that a thing is possible when done correctly, it irritates me to all ends to watch so many not following that working model.
We still have too much me and us and them, not enough we.
As for those women in that alternate universe? I expect some may have missed your point (preconceived notions are difficult to shake loose from or see around with any clarity) but hopefully others caught it :). The thought of truly having the ability to simply *be* who and what you are without all of the 'social constructs' we've built for ourselves over the centuries.. now that *is* a fine dream :).
Rated for clearly there's a reason Joan Walsh is Joan Walsh :D.
Excellent post. Rated.
Although sometimes it would be nice to go to other sorts of parallel universes.
Is that what it is, they prefer being lied to? Because I narrowed it down to either severe tribalism or severe ignorance or both. To vote against one's interest just to piss off intellectuals is hardly a personality. Thank you so much for your thoughtful comment and gracious visit.
@ Jack Heart
I remember learning in school that the press was subsidized not only at the time of the founding fathers, but also before that by the British. I am not sure and I need more research on that, but how ironic. I agree, our foreign policy should match our status as a super power, not a predator. Thank you, my friend for your kind words and needed insight.
@ Cathy GF
He is a very good doctor. His relentless pursuit of patient's history directed him to the cause of my hypertension. Thanks you, Cathy, it is always good to see you.
@InZain
Thank you so much, Game Master, long time no see.
@ Linda Seccaspina
It is upside down. You would think that a people's movement should be very popular with journalists. I guess that is not what it says in this weeks office memo. Thank you, Linda, as always.
OK! I will trust you with my special-top-secret-recipe. Thank you so much for your visit.
@ Bellwether Vance
That is it, "speech control." Money should never be allowed to control the media. It should be taken out of politics. Thank you, BV, as always for your gracious visit and insight.
I know, me too. I am going to give here a chance and then move there. Thanks, VC, for you kind visit.
@ Seer
You are so wise my dear intellectual friend. You always have a keen sense of analysis, and you always get it right. Kudos on the brains, that was very clever. Thank you so much, Seer, it is always a pleasure reading your mind.
@ fernsy,
Why, thank you my good friend. How about you lead and I will be your policy adviser?
@ jramelle
But healthcare is free, so problem solved! Thank you so much for your visit and thoughtful comment.
@ Mary Stanik
Actually, I don't think you are going to like it, but I heard some talk about the location of her new operation in Minnesota. Nah, just kidding. Thank you, Mary, it is always good to see you.
@ Abrawang
Yeah, I know, it was as if they were reading from a script. Get ready for the new script, this time it's Iran. This should be fun. Thank you so much, my friend for your support.
You characterize politics as a compromise where the poor and middle class get fucked. You then proceed to go on a long-winded rant against prominent Republicans and don’t mention a single Democrat. In other words, you’re upset because the political party you supported didn’t do the things you wanted them to do, despite having the power not to compromise with Republicans. For a Republican it’s very entertaining watching die hard Democrats make sense of the mess we’re in. I don’t blame you all for illegally occupying community parkland and look forward to the day when the police finally do their job.
...Okay, okay--I can see that.
♥R
Lezlie
Thank you so much for your kind words; always good to see you.
@ Johnny Fever
I am sorry you don't like my view of a different America, but never call me a democrat again. Thank you so much for reading.
@ My Heart on a String
Thank you so much for your support.
Ha! Why, thank you so much, Fusun. It is always good to see your avatar.
@ DandyLion
It is an Open Salon, Sir; thank you so much for reading.
I know exactly what you mean. Thank you as always for your gracious visit and support.
Thank you so much for your visit and kind words. It is a pleasure to make your acquaintance.
-pawed-
Why, thank you so much, coming from a great artist like you, this is much appreciated. Thanks again for gracious visit.
@ LadyMiko
Thank you my dear friend. Just read your moving and beautiful words on your blog. You have my best wishes.
Amen! Amen! Thank you maestro for your gracious visit and insight.
I don't watch TV. And this post is exactly what I love about 2011. I read, everything, the back of cereal boxes, discarded lotto tickets.
Salon has made it possible for me to not have to break my back picking up such nonsense. I do not have to budget in Barnes and Noble or that other gone the way of near do wells. I can come on here and be PROPerLY entertained.
Love You
Mean it
D
I was a mother that went back to school. O'Bama pushed us to do that. Sure no one held a gun to my head. But letters came through the mail in droves, I had a high grade point average before, and I had always wanted to graduate. I will graduate by the end of this year and apply to graduate school for a masters in anthropology, after I take a couple classes I need to help homeschool my son. I hope to work on a comparison in pagan and cultural rituals, their different meaning and how the church used different pagan rituals and symbols to convince different regions and cultures to join the church. Ok so I'm getting off subject sorry, but yeah their promises that I was not sure I believed really hurt us financially along with many other changes they did not put into affect. Your alternate world is nice, wish I lived there.
That is what I love about you; you always say it like it is. Thank you, Mary for your gracious visit.
@ Dianne Schuch-Lindsey
It was the first time I see Joan on TV. She made OS proud being so suave and elegant.
@ Bedelia Nightshade
This what Joan said with such tact. The voters were lied to, the change did not happen, and many suffered. Thank you so much for your thoughtful comment and gracious visit.
Once, many years ago, I bought a book for pennies at a library fair in Upstate NY. The book was a collection of the letters of Thomas Jefferson.
One letter to someone explained that he wanted the US to be a country of the rich, for the rich, and run by the rich.
Jefferson succeeded. We lost.
R
Say it ain't so! I am trying to forget that, Pierre, or at least give him the benefit of the doubt. Some of the founding fathers were not that greedy. Thank you so much for your comment and gracious visit.
Democratic socialism with a free market (which is what we have here) is more realistic. You have to maintain that free market for commerce trades, and jobs, people have to pay taxes to support the programs. I pay taxes in two countries, I see the difference in the mindset of people. My taxes here are actually lower than what I paid in the US. I have seen first hand the abuse of the system in the US, people getting aid and benefits when they really could go to work. Why bother working?
We all want Utopia, unfortunately it doesn't exist in this universe.
We can make our own Utopia within our own lives and hearts.
Why, thank you so much for your visit and kind words.
@ Poppi Island
Hey, Poppi! How are you? It is always a treat to see you on my blog. And yes, we can only dream for anything even close to a Utopia. Thank you for the gracious visit.
Thank you, Janice, for your gracious visit and kind words. Looking forward to your next post.
A fine, though sad read.
Rated.
Absolutely, that is the current American Way; we can only dream to change it. Always good to see you, my friend.
@ Bert Wylen
When any politician anywhere in the world, other than the US, says "We are doing such and such for the people," he/she means the majority of the people who need help. That the government's main job is to help those who need help is a universal notion--again, except in America. Why? Because the rich DO NOT need help. Let me repeat that again: the rich do not need help. Therefore that the government should promote social programs is a given.
The word 'free' here will always mean free from enslavement by the big money. It should always mean that. To try to explain it otherwise, for example, as being free from a foreign occupation is spin and bullshit.
The government's first priority is to care for those who need care. Again, the rich can take care of themselves.
The government will only subsidize that which promote social programs. That which promotes social programs is called free press. Anything that promotes the interest of big money is corrupt spin. Thank you so much for your visit and insight.
I am still waiting to have a complete sense of what, specifically, the Occupiers want. People try to speak for them, but that is not right. I am certainly one of the 99%, but I am keeping my eyes and ears open, wanting to learn and hoping for the best. What, I wonder, will be defined as success? The government stepping in and putting limits on what a person can earn in the U.S.? Trading has been going on since the beginning of time. Is that to stop? If more of the very rich like Gates, Buffet, Zuckerberg, et al, pledge to give half of their money away, would that do it? Do what? I wonder if old ladies in their investment and knitting clubs are also the enemies? In one of your other posts you suggested a free press could be sort of, if I remember correctly, be supported by government. Oil and water don't mix. What the government spends money on, it wants a say in what goes on.
My niece and nephew are making their way through school, working hard to earn money to pay the fees and to earn academic scholarships to help. They haven't said, but I believe they are proud of what they are working to do without debt. It seems lately that university education is looked down up on too, by some.
I do not remember exactly, but would going back to the tax rates of the Clinton years make the protesters happy, or is the U.S. too far in debt now for that to make a dent? Solutions often seen simple but are decidedly not. I sit here, with my voting card and $3 in my wallet, wondering... R
The status quo is very dark, but solid and probably permanent. All we can do is dream. BTW, I miss your posts.
not economic ones,
but spiritual ones.
spiritual infiltration into narcissistic nihilistic bad manners
will hopefully devastate holders of the post capitalist dream
into humiliating wakefulness. Not from concern for others,
let's not fool ourselfs, but from
the evolutionary imperative of grabbing the current zeitgeist.
which is; revolutionary.
You are one fine philosopher, my friend. I wish more and more people would listen.
thanks so much for this ....I love your vision too...everything from the free education to the ridicuousness of the super white teeth...funny and right on.
Hey, Heidi, welcome back. Thank you so much for your visit and kind words.
Thank you. I am about to email you. Love
Wendy
Hey, Wendy! It is always great to see you. Thank you so much for your gracious visit and kind words. R
Thank you so much for your kind words. Good to have made your acquaintance.
The poem, just perfect.
rated with love
I love Belloc. Thank you so much for your kind words and gracious visit.
Thank you my friend; it is always a pleasure to see you here.
Actually, they don't even try to hide it anymore. It is insane. Thank you for your visit. It is a pleasure to make your acquaintance.
rollon to the roll.
rolling like a moss speck.
fulla dna.
on mars/?
coulda been. artjames lives there.
george my dad is th moon.
i am the earth gaia interstices.
u are the cali boy. from europa,thoth. egypt on fire.
good show.