The late Ayatollah Khomeni once infamously issued a fatwa calling for the death of Salman Rushdie, author of The Satanic Verses, a book based loosely on a controversy dating back to the founding of Islam.
The Prophet Muhammad, the self-proclaimed Messenger of God/Allah, was illiterate and had to dictate the verses in the Qur'an to a scribe. Apparently, he later retracted some of those verses claiming he had been deceived by Satan posing as God. That sort of thing tends to call into question a claim of infallibility or divine revelation.
This controversy comes to mind because functionally illiterate Reverend Pat Robertson – preacher, pundit, politico, pontificator and prognosticator has issued another of his infantile “edicts” – in which he ascribes the cause of yet another natural disaster to Divine Retribution.
Most educated people are content to attribute natural disasters to natural causes, but Robertson sees them as punishment inflicted by God on people who don’t obey. Thus Katrina was the work of a wrathful God striking out in anger in reaction to “secular humanists” and social activists advocating for abortion and gay rights.
The problem with Robertson’s “logic” is that a lot of innocent people, including little children, get caught in these disasters, and it seems fair to say that punishing the innocent for the sins of the guilty sounds more like the work of Satan.
Could it be that the verses Robertson selectively plucks from that other supposedly divinely-inspired text the Bible were inspired by some other source? And could it be that the voice echoing in Robertson's head is not that of God but that of Satan?
That possibility ought to occur to Robertson (but it won't), since predictions he makes based on his “inside information” so often fail to materialize. He predicted the world would end in 1982, but obviously that didn’t come to pass. Nor did a tsunami hit the Pacific Northwest (and lord knows secular humanists in league with Satan – or is it Bill Gates – control the Pacific Northwest) in 2006 as he predicted. Nor did the US suffer a terrorist attack worse than 9/11 in 2007 as he predicted.
• • •
Robertson’s latest outrage was prompted by a massive earthquake that devastated Haiti, leveling its capital city Port au Prince and leaving an estimated 150,000 dead and 3,000,000 homeless. According to the heartless Robertson, this isn’t a tragedy, it’s a just and fitting punishment dispensed by a god still pissed about a centuries-old slave rebellion.
"They were under the heel of the French ... and they got together and swore a pact to the devil. They said, 'We will serve you if you'll get us free from the French. True story. And so the devil said, 'OK, it's a deal.' They kicked the French out. The Haitians revolted and got themselves free. Ever since, they have been cursed by one thing after the other."
While these remarks are unimaginably and unforgivably thoughtless and cruel, they also reveal that Robertson is as ignorant of history as he is his own religion. Has he never heard of the Caribe, the Taino and the Arawak, the Indian tribes that once populated these islands? And what is it they did to deserve mass extinction?
Apparently, Robertson’s god feels white folks don’t deserve Divine Retribution for five centuries of rape, plunder and genocide.
• • •
Robertson is so ignorant he makes the late Jerry Falwell look like Spinoza; and he is so lacking in compassion, he makes Ann Coulter look like Mother Theresa. His pronouncements wouldn’t be worthy of a response if millions didn’t take him seriously. But they do.
For Robertson and his followers, Satan is no metaphor for evil; he is as real as a heart-attack; he is a demonic fiery-red fallen angel; he is a gothic gargoyle come to life, stalking the Earth to rob, rape and foment rebellion against God.
It’s all so medieval it would be laughable – if it didn’t get some people killed and other people elected. Where ignorance and intolerance are admired and celebrated, it can lead to mass insanity. Just ask the Germans.
And speaking of insanity, claiming to hear voices and exhibiting delusions of grandeur used to get you locked up in a padded cell in a loony bin. But in 20th/21st Century America, insanity gets you a television show and a following of millions. Just ask Glenn Beck.
It’s enough to make even a hardened secular humanist begin to wonder if we aren’t in the End Times.
• • •
But let us suppose for the sake of argument that Robertson and his followers are correct about the way the Big Guy operates, suppose Haiti’s troubles are the result of God cursing the island because former slaves made a voodoo pact with the Devil to throw off their oppressors – that would certainly explain our current economic woes.
Those woes would be a fitting punishment for a people who made a pact with the Devil back in 1980, a pact rightly characterized by George H.W. Bush as Voodoo Economics. In that pact, the people of America agreed to take from those who had least and give to those who had most – forgetting the Christian imperative to feed the poor and ignoring the clear warning that “even as you have done unto the least of these, so also have you done unto me”.
Divine retribution would certainly explain why a lifelong loser was placed in the most powerful position on Earth despite losing by half-a-million votes in the 2000 election. And just as God kept the sun hanging in the heavens for Joshua, so Divine intervention might have kept all those chads hanging on ballots in Florida. Divine intervention could also explain the suspect results from electronic voting machines in Ohio, though a less than divine intervention seems far more likely.
• • •
Permit me a moment of levity in this otherwise depressing diatribe; allow me to draw another parallel with the Haitian pact with Satan. Like the Haitians, the makers of this satanic pact demonized the French so thoroughly French fries had to be rebranded as Freedom fries and sales of French’s mustard plummeted – though in fairness, it must be said the French were more than happy to have been dissociated with both products.
Of course this manufactured “hatred” of the French was hardly as justifiable as the Haitians’, and it was certainly more superficial, as evidenced by the fact that so many of those most vocal about demonizing the French were as fond of French wines as they were Cuban cigars.
But perhaps the Devil made them do it – after all, it’s well-known that alcohol is the Devil’s doing – though the same can’t be said for tobacco – at least not in Robertson’s part of the country where tobacco is still a blessed sacrament.
• • •
Robertson enthusiastically supported this pact with the Devil; defended it vociferously even when Voodoo Economics 2.0 cut taxes for the wealthy again, this time during an ill-advised war based on trumped-up charges of a Saddam/Al Queda connection and suspect evidence of WMD.
Even a secular humanist could see Satan at work in that because a secular humanist can see what Pat Robertson apparently can’t – Satan doesn’t run around in a Halloween costume – that would be like trying to rob a bank wearing prison garb.
On the contrary, Satan is frequently found in an expensive three-piece suit, sporting braided leather suspenders and a $400 dollar haircut. Satan attended prep school and graduated from a prestigious university with a degree in Business Manipulation.
Satan says greed is good.
Satan says God wants him to be rich.
Satan says there's a sucker born every minute.
Satan invented derivatives.Satan has an expensive condo facing Central Park, a summer place in the Hamptons, a Bentley, a Hummer and a Lear Jet. Satan also has an ex-wife and heavy alimony payments. All this keeps Satan chasing the great god Dollar.
Satan plays fast and loose with other people’s money. Satan convinces people to lie about their income on a loan application. Satan tricks unsophisticated buyers into signing for home loans with exploding interest rates, balloon payments and inevitable defaults.
Satan believes it's his right and duty to enrich himself at other people's expense. Satan is a fervent capitalist who vows his undying love for the free-market but abandons it at the first sign of trouble and pronounces his business too big to fail.
Satan is a bankster who uses unscrupulous tactics and usurious rates to force the public to repay loans the public made to his bank and pays himself an obscene bonus for being so diabolically clever. Satan has backdated stock options and a golden parachute.
Satan doesn’t believe in government or social welfare or paying taxes; he avoids rendering unto Caesar, and he stashes away the profits from his schemes in an off-shore account.
Satan is a lobbyist who lavishes wine, women and golf outings on legislators in order to influence their vote. Satan is a legislator who accepts these bribes, votes against the public interest and pronounces himself a fiscal conservative free from the influence of campaign contributions and lobbying largess.
Satan is very well-connected. Satan belongs to the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute, and he signed onto the Project for a New American Century. Satan is the slick dick who fudges intelligence to justify an unnecessary war in order to enrich his friends and his former employer with billions in no-bid contracts.
Satan is the uncaring compassionate conservative who fiddles while Rome burns – or plunks a guitar while New Orleans drowns. Satan sees an entire city in ruins, sees bodies rotting in the streets and says “Heckuva job” to one of his minions.
• • •
No, Satan isn’t who Pat Robertson and his followers think he is, and those looking to blame the biblical Satan for all this world’s woes are as mistaken as those looking to find Jesus in Robertson’s ignorant "revelations".
Frankly, I’ve had enough of Pat Robertson and his Satanic Curses. And while I consider a fatwa too extreme even for his blasphemy, it would be a blessing if he was made to sit down and shut up.
But that will probably take an act of God.
©2010 Tom Cordle


Salon.com
Comments
R
Great line! This strain of evangelicalism is overwrought with grandiose behavior. It is challenging to see where there is any virtues of love or honoring our neighbors when someone behaves as extremely as Pat Robertson. To think people like this have influence over policy due to things like the Religious Freedom Act is unnerving. This earned them a state department office and through their wiggling in with abolitionist feminists, they have made deals with conservatives which have actually led to some of the things we are seeing such as the Stupak amendement. It is insane.
Control is control. Freedom will be found when we quit trying to legislate one another's choices and see the difference between choice and force.
Good point save that I prefer to think of Robertson as an unnatural disaster
Indiana Joe
Who'syer Prophet
Not only is the difference between choice and force, there is a difference between fierce and farce, but the worst of all worlds is when fierce is farce -- see Fundamentalism
Thank you
Wherever we�re from
We shoulda noticed by now
Our behavior is dumb
And if our chances
Expect to improve
It�s gonna take a lot more
Than tryin� to remove
The other race
Or the other whatever
From the face
Of the planet altogether
They call it the earth
Which is a dumb kinda name
But they named it right
�cause we behave the same...
We are dumb all over
Dumb all over,
Yes we are
Dumb all over,
Near �n far
Dumb all over,
Black �n white
People, we is not wrapped tight
Nurds on the left
Nurds on the right
Religous fanatics
On the air every night
Sayin� the bible
Tells the story
Makes the details
Sound real gory
�bout what to do
If the geeks over there
Don�t believe in the book
We got over here
You can�t run a race
Without no feet
�n pretty soon
There won�t be no street
For dummies to jog on
Or doggies to dog on
Religous fanatics
Can make it be all gone
(I mean it won�t blow up
�n disappear
It�ll just look ugly
For a thousand years...)
You can�t run a country
By a book of religion
Not by a heap
Or a lump or a smidgeon
Of foolish rules
Of ancient date
Designed to make
You all feel great
While you fold, spindle
And mutilate
Those unbelievers
From a neighboring state
To arms! to arms!
Hooray! that�s great
Two legs ain�t bad
Unless there�s a crate
They ship the parts
To mama in
For souvenirs: two ears (get down!)
Not his, not hers, (but what the hey? )
The good book says:
("it gotta be that way!")
But their book says:
"revenge the crusades...
With whips �n chains
�n hand grenades..."
Two arms? two arms?
Have another and another
Our God says:
"there ain�t no other!"
Our God says
"it�s all okay!"
Our God says
"this is the way!"
It says in the book:
"burn �n destroy...
�n repent, �n redeem
�n revenge, �n deploy
�n rumble thee forth
To the land of the unbelieving scum on the other side
�cause they don�t go for what�s in the book
�n that makes �em bad
So verily we must choppeth them up
And stompeth them down
Or rent a nice french bomb
To poof them out of existance
While leaving their real estate just where we need it
To use again
For temples in which to praise our god
("cause he can really take care of business!")
And when his humble tv servant
With humble white hair
And humble glasses
And a nice brown suit
And maybe a blond wife who takes phone calls
Tells us our God says
It�s okay to do this stuff
Then we gotta do it,
�cause if we don�t do it,
We ain�t gwine up to hebbin!
(depending on which book you�re using at the
Time...can�t use theirs... it don�t work
...it�s all lies...gotta use mine...)
Ain�t that right?
That�s what they say
Every night...
Every day...
Hey, we can�t really be dumb
If we�re just following god�s orders
Hey, let�s get serious...
God knows what he�s doin�
He wrote this book here
An� the book says:
He made us all to be just like him,"
So...
If we�re dumb...
Then God is dumb...
"Dumb all over" by Frank Zappa
Loved this post. Placing link at mine from yesterday Tom.
A great commentary by the Mother from Another Planet
Anne
I wish I didn't have to
Which reminds me of that verse from another sacred text:
"First, we kill all the lawyers."
I saw a clip that was used in a documentary to close the SOA which has Robertson talking about how we should assassinate Hugh Chavez. Of course, the oil in Venezuela is mentioned. How does being a Bible thumper give you the right to pass out assassination orders?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DykgMyTjWU4
Thank you -- that's how we roll on the road less traveled.
If that's how he works, let me just apologize to my descendants now for the trouble I made that they'll have to pay for.
Once again, I rant vicariously through you because you do it better than I. You outline the ignorance and hypocrisy so well.
To be honest, I’ve just grown a bit weary of expressing these obvious excursions into lunacy that are defended under the banner of religious freedom and tolerance. It goes in cycles for me; I rant, I expose, and then I back away to recharge because the energy required is such that I must.
You write, “…he is so lacking in compassion, he makes Ann Coulter look like Mother Theresa”
It’s a funny line, but it doesn’t ring true for me. I don’t think ANYONE or ANYTHING could accomplish that feat. She’s just smarter than he is, but I haven’t seen any evidence of “compassion” in her.
“Where ignorance and intolerance are admired and celebrated, it can lead to mass insanity…”
…and mass insanity breeds ignorance, intolerance and religion. It’s a self-perpetuating cycle. As I’ve said many times, if these people weren’t so many, they’d all be locked up in rubber rooms and made to wear straightjackets so as not to hurt themselves.
Satan is …
Yes, and if I'm not mistaken, your apology will have to extend at least unto the seventh generation -- it's the Old Math.
IMom
If I had it to do all over again, I probably would find some quiet little out of the way liberal arts college and spend my life infected unsuspected students with my skepticism.
I too would find a fatwa somewhat extreme even in Robertson's case.
A perpetual case of laryngitis, however......
Rated.
Yes, and if I'm not mistaken, your apology will have to extend at least unto the seventh generation -- it's the Old Math.
IMom
If I had it to do all over again, I probably would find some quiet little out of the way liberal arts college and spend my life infecting unsuspecting students with my skepticism.
How well I understand the weariness -- it is particularly wearisome holding my views here in the buckle of the Bible Belt
Bill
Your observation is greatly appreciated, but I fear you are not the first to make it. I was once introduced as a singer/songwriter who could make you laugh and cry -- sometimes in the same song.
Yes, and the devil frequents the finest places
There is a great book on this by Twain, Letters from the Earth, that is Twain at his most, most savage, and very, very funny.
If a tower falls on eighteen people and kills them, folks of Robertson's ilk are quick to point out the reason must be in the victims lives somewhere.
Suffering on the magnitude of what is being experienced in Haiti is terrible enough.
Robertson expressed the mercy of a falling rock with his twisted “insight.”
This kind of response to human suffering reminds me of the man who tossed a Cherry lifesaver to a drowning boy.
Rated and appreciated.
{[R]}
Good work here. Rated.
The UK, happily, is a Reverend-Pat-Robertson-free environment. However, on this side of the pond he'd be a mere laughing-stock; the farce/force ratio would be incomparably greater than it appears to be in the States. He'd exert no political influence and would be very unlikely to enjoy any TV exposure. His wealth would accordingly contract to the extent that he'd have to get a real job. Maybe he'd have to return to the practice of law.
Do you want to deport him? We could use some entertainment over here. Though we have much, much better sick humorists already, home-grown.
The Unholy Trinity -- I like it
BluTX
This is my version of The Devil Wears Prada
If he had been there when Jesus was protecting the prostitute, Pat would probably have cast the first stone
Why indeed?
Ashes to ashes, dust to dust
R+P= DNC
No, not the Democratic National Committee -- Does Not Compute
This is one of the best rants/indictments of the power-brokers and greed-mongers I've ever seen. I don't know what else to say, but WOW. Thanks for putting it out there.
Much to the dismay of Robertson et al I'm not sitting in the fires of hell just yet -- but thank you for the kind words, tho because of them, you may end up with a spot next to me in Hades
Since Rushdie is still a resident of your fair country, I'm sure this has a special appeal to you -- especially since you don't have to contend with RevPat
Alas, ranting is my main accomplishment in life
Stellaa
The beat-down goes on, and I don't mean the voodoo drums
At the risk of being even more sacrilegious, you'll know him by the nail-prints on his blog
AJ
On balance, you're balanced -- I wish I could say the same for Pat he strikes me as more than a little unbalanced
Did Tom Cordle just deliver the best Satan rant ever? Suffice it to say that this is going on my Delicious list.
Sad to say, trying to understand the "thinking" of the willfully blind is an exercise in futility. But as you point out, the irony in all this is delicious -- if indigestible.
Rated.
BTW, "Satan is frequently found in an expensive three-piece suit, sporting braided leather suspenders and a $400 dollar haircut ..."
I always wondered why my lawyer's office had that rotten egg smell.
Rated.
Robertson is at best an ass and at worst a daemon, and a careless, clueless, lesser one at that. Perhaps one thing that you missed is actually in order: exorcism is still practiced by some. Do you think..........?
Anyway, every now and then a truly righteous rant is well justified and I would think that this one rates right up there with the best. I believe that even Screwtape would envy your cutting to the heart of the matter. "Jack" Lewis must be proud of you, as am I.
Monte
I think you and I both channel Twain, at least his darker side.
Tink
Some of us do care, but we feel helpless to do anything except pull the mask off the Devil incarnate whenever we get the chance
Thanks
Trudge
If I were Pat, I wouldn't go out in a lightning storm -- and I think I'd stay away from Port au Prince, too
I admit this post helped me exorcise a few demons from myself, demons visited upon me by Robertson's thoughtless, heartless, clueless remarks.
And thank you, I am pleased, to say the least, to be compared to either Mr Lewis -- C.S. or Sinclair.
Thanks for weighing in on this, and I'm sure you won't mind my saying it doesn't take a prophet to forsee Pat or Rush spouting racist nonsense when death, devastation and the devil are visited upon people of color. Scratch that -- who needs the Devil when you've got people like Pat and Rush?
Glad you came in from the cold -- I wish I could explain it, but the simple truth is that logic can't be applied when dealing with the insane
PS Next time I'm going to use an automatic poetry generator to create a post.
And his followers don't have a pot to piss in, bu they still think they can buy their way into Heaven. CBN - (Anti)Christ Broadcasting Network