TMaita

TMaita
Location
I know I'm out here somewhere, California, USA
Birthday
May 26
Title
Psychotherapist
Bio
"Oh, what sad times are these when passing ruffians can say `nee' at will to old ladies. There is a pestilence upon this land, nothing is sacred. Even those who arrange and design shrubberies are under considerable economic stress at this period in history."

TMaita's Links

New list
No links in this category.
JUNE 7, 2009 4:12PM

An Open Letter To Neil Young

Rate: 15 Flag

neil 

 

Dear Neil                                                                                                                                

 It’s Sunday evening, and my husband and I are sitting on the couch in front of the television. I’m watching a show about Rommel, and my husband is reading The Rolling Stone. He just read to me about the release of your long awaited Archives, and started playing a trailer for the DVD on his computer. 

 

He muted the television--- I was really only half watching Rommel as he and his defeated forces were fleeing Africa, and I began listening to the trailer. As I did, I was flooded with memories of my childhood—my adolescence really, and I began to cry, and I quickly stepped out to the backyard for a moment of reflection. It was then that I finally decided to write you this letter, to finally tell you before it’s too late, why I was flooded with such emotion. 

 

When I was 13, I listened to my sister’s copy of Harvest. I guess this was in 1974. While the whole of my neighborhood in Castro Valley was listening to Ten Years After and Led Zeppelin, I was shut up in my bedroom, playing Harvest over and over again, and I was off and running. It was not long before I got a copy of everything that you had recorded previously, and started playing the guitar, learning your songs. I was particularly fond of “The Last Trip To Tulsa”. I would sit there and bang that song out, feeling that you were my only muse. And you were Neil. You were indeed someone in my life who I clung to, who I felt would understand my very painful feelings. It seemed so natural that I would project all of my desperate needs on to you.  

 

My family life was disintegrating. Suddenly, my mother of 50 had turned into a caricature of Mrs. Robinson, and my dear father, who would die when I was 15, was becoming unglued. Our house was a battle zone; every new day brought an emotionally wrenching situation, and my only escape was music. I would go into my bedroom and play your records, over and over again. I bought each new record as they were released, learned all of the lyrics, tried to play them on my guitar, and soothed myself with the idea that at least there was something for me to hang on to. Listening to your songs, digesting each word, somehow gave me a kind of hope---certainly it comforted me in ways that I am extremely grateful to you for. 

 

I’ll always remember a favor that a family friend did for me. He was with your label at the time and has been a long time family friend. When I was 14, I called him and begged him to do something, honestly I don’t remember what. I don’t know what I could have wanted, to meet you? I don’t really recall. What I did receive was an autographed picture that I still own, and it reads: “Toni, fly, fly, fly, Neil Young.” When I got this, well, how would you expect a 14-year-old girl to behave? I was elated. 

 

Over the years, I followed you, bought your new releases, and went to your concerts. I saw you on my 17th birthday at the Boarding House in San Francisco. We came for 2 of those performances. What a great way to spend my birthday. I also saw you at the Cow Palace when you recorded “Rust Never Sleeps”. That was one hell of a show. I’ve had great opportunities to see you, experience how you have evolved, how you have stayed the same, changed, yet never really changed at all. 

 

I can’t tell you how many of your songs are my favorite songs. I often tell people that I believe that “Like A Hurricane” is the best rock song that I have ever heard. I still crank that song up to a painful volume and soar with you, never being set back down on earth until the very last chord. 

 

Anyway Neil, I just needed for you to know right now, while I have the nerve to write this letter, that you helped me breathe when I was a kid. You offered me a lifeline, and you never even knew it. You helped a sad and frightened girl connect with something when it seemed that there was no one and nothing to connect to. You gave that to me, and when I listen to you now, still, my heart feels connected to you in a way that perhaps only few would understand. 

 

Thank you Neil, for everything, always.   

 

Author tags:

teen angst, neil young

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Very sweet Toni. I hope with the magic of the web, this letter finds its destination.
I love this. I swear, music saves lives every day.

Well done.
I am saw him only once live, and never forgot it, My fave is Hey Hey My My, second Like a Hurricane, followed by Harvest moon.

But I Love so many, my faves keep changing every time I hear another.

rated for nostalgia
Ablonde--I know that experience is universal, music can be so intensely personal and important.

Brie--He may get it. That family friend is sending it on, but it really doesn't matter, I just wanted to express this, no matter who hears.

Waking--Love your poetry so much. Thanks for being here.

Markinjapan--Yes, there are too many good songs by Neil!

Thanks you guys!
Interesting. It's almost like reading my own life on this post. However, my story has a different ending. After learning to play every song he ever wrote in 4 instruments, worshipping the ground he walked on ... I finally got to meet Neil in-person. I approached him with grace and humility, only to have him basically tell me to f*ck off. Crushed and humiliated, I never bought anything else he ever made. Lately, I have been listening to his old music, and remember how much of my life I spent loving Neil Young and his music. Don't get me wrong, his music is still meaningful to me; I just felt that his extreme verbal cruelty to a young female fan, was really devastating to me for many years. Neil, if you're reading this, I hope you'll recognize how impressionable young fans need to be treated with compassion. Peace. ~Laylah~ (an old friend of Breau's, from Toronto).
I enjoyed your letter to Mr. Young.

Just last evening I was at a friend's home and he gave me a show and tell of his recently purchased first volume of the Neil Young archives. My friend is a musician, audio engineer and computer geek. It was a lengthy show and tell. There are some wonderful pictures in the book.

Wednesday night Neil Young is the subject for American Masters on PBS.
There is a town, in north Ontario...
Neil is one of the few who follows his own muse where ever it goes, and it works. Goodness, does it work. I love Harvest and Havest Moon, and many others.

A cousin of mine says that "I (heart) NY" stands for "I Love Neil Young."
The whole tone of a Neil Young song is an era. A time.
I hope when the kids hear his music that they might get a sense of this. It's transporting.
In his new record, 'Fork in the Road' he says something like,
'twist and shout on the radio, bring it back!
How cool is that?!
Laylah - Yep, I've heard over the years that he really can has tight boundaries, doesn't let too many people in. That's sad though, that he couldn't have been more understanding.

livemonster - I like Harvest, but there are so many other records that I think are really superior!

Cindy - The Needle and the Damage Done. I can still play that on my guitar!

consonant - Thanks for the heads up about the PBS special.

Moses - right on.

Ignatz - That's great! I love NY!

Timsored - Fork in the road, great record!

Thanks to all of you for posting your thoughts about Neil, and about what music has meant to you, how it has made you felt, how it has saved you, uplifted you, kept you company when you were lonely or in despair.
Just a very cool post. Music can really get you through sometimes. I'm glad it helped you.
Neil Young taught much through his music.
I too hope the magic of the Internet gets this in front of Neil's eyes. He's certainly among the best of the best, both as songwriter and performer. Thanks for allowing us to read your letter to him.
Very nice.

Did you watch the American Masters on him? It should be replaying over and over on PBS. It was very good, could have been longer, deeper.

I was lured here by the "There is a town, in north Ontario..." quote I saw on someone's comments page. I love that line. I wrote my undergrad intro rhet term paper on him, and how he was better than Bob Dylan.

I used that line as an example of how we were taught that "There is . . . " opening to a sentence is a weak construction, and it generally is, but that song illustrated how powerful exceptions can be. It's perfect.

I actually modeled a chapter of my book on it. The copy editors kept trying to change the opening line of the chapter, but I refused. It inspired the whole thing.

I like the next few lines, too. I think:

There is a town, in north Ontario
With dream comfort memory to spare
And in my mind I still need a place to go
All . . . my changes were there.

(I didn't look it up, some I might have a few misses.)

Neil is my all-time second-fave, after The Clash. And no one has been more exquisite longer.
Sactogator- I hesitated sharing something so personal, but really, it is a piece that so many can relate to.

Mr Mustard - You are like a hurricane! ;-)

Lonnie- Thanks, and make sure that I know when the next West Coast OS gathering happens!

Dave- You are too cool. There is so much I would like to express. There is a big hairy dog lying on my bed.

There is a deep fog enveloping the Bay Area tonight.

There is so much more to say.
"You helped me breathe when I was a kid" I have never heard it said better than that. This is just wonderful---a piece to a person who couldn't be more deserving. I pretty much love everything about him; but if I had to pick one thing---it's that he never stopped changing.
Wonderful tribute to a guy who never really sold-out. As someone who resembles Neil in every way but talent and success, I invite you to stop in at The Castle in Tellico Plains, TN some Saturday night, and I'll perform Down by the River or Mr. Soul for you.
Hey Tom

I have never been to TN. Been all around it, but I'll make you a deal, if I ever come, I will look you up, and you can serenade me with Down By The River. E minor 7, A major!
I joined salon.com just to comment on your post. I'm listening to Live Rust right now, I'm 54 years old, and Neil Young means the same thing to me that he seems to mean to you. There's almost something holy about him... just recently, I wanted to write him a thank-you note (can you tell how old I am? I'm hard-wired to write thank-you notes)... I had to drive over the Bay Bridge last weekend during a terrible rainstorm and I was so scared, and I prayed for God to do something to calm me... lo and behold, a live show of Neil Young came on the radio and I got over the bridge, singing Helpless the whole time. That's not the first time God has given me the gift of Neil Young to soothe my soul. Neil Young has carried me through any number of difficult times in my single life, married life, mom life, and daughter life way back when. I just want to add my gratitude to Neil Young for helping me through many a soul-crushing experience...and thanks for your post Toni. It made me cry, there's something very comforting knowing there are others out there, especially other women, who deal with their private griefs and find solace in the same things. Blessings upon you, Toni. I can only imagine what that signed photo meant to you!!