After 20 Years, I Want to See My Abusive Dad for His Money
Less than two months before my high-school graduation, my father told me he never wanted to see me again. He had received a summons that week and was furious that I had known but not warned him my mom was going to file a lawsuit against him.
The conflict involved a joint bank account my parents had set up for my future college education when I was a young child. For years, they mutually contributed to the modest savings plan. Yet after their divorce, a protracted and gut-wrenching break-up that gnawed away at my insides while I was on the verge of puberty in the sixth grade, only my mother continued to direct a slice of her earnings toward my schooling. Now that I was eighteen, the account had reached maturity. But my dad was refusing to sign the form that would allow my mom to apply the money to my tuition, books, and dorm expense. Consequently, she decided to press the issue through legal measures. From my perspective it was a messy affair the grown-ups should solve—not a situation that called for the engagement of a kid whose understanding of finances consisted of little more than knowing the price of a quarter pounder with cheese. My dad, however, felt differently. As a result, I would have to wave my diploma in front of only one proud parent clapping in the audience.
My father’s rejection was definitely a blow. Still, I shouldn’t have been surprised, given his track record. After all, this was a cruel man who had tormented me throughout my childhood, generating far too many indelible, piercing memories along the way. Like the time he went on a wild tirade through an entire wash cycle because I had splashed through a few puddles on my way home from school. Or the time he threw me into the bedroom after choking me in the hall, then a few minutes later called me out of the room to ask with a syrupy voice if he had hurt me, and finally screamed after I had nodded yes through my tears, “GOOD!” Or the time, as my mother came to a halt in the driveway to take me swimming after she had vanished for days to escape my father’s unending wrath, he slugged her so hard that she bit her tongue, oozing her warm blood onto the front seat. Or the time he verbally assaulted me, then 11-years-old, for not fighting the divorce my mother had recently put in motion. Or the time, while my parents were separated before the divorce was final, my mom and I checked into a motel for the night because she had received a call from her best friend saying she had just heard from my father, who had revealed he was on his way to murder us. Or the time I came home after a pony-league baseball game to discover my battered mother shivering and huddled in a corner after my father had broken into the house through the milk shoot to greet her with physical aggression. Or the Sundays he would pick me up after the divorce, speed 60-miles-an-hour down the residential street from my house with an expression straight out of a horror film, stop in a parking lot, then viciously explain to me that my mother was a pig and a whore who hung out with other pigs and whores. Needless to say, my dad was no Ward Cleaver.
***
Four years into my undergraduate studies, on the advice of the therapist I had been seeing since the previous summer, I reached out to my father, hoping to reestablish a bond. Things were better for a while. As a perceptive young adult about to graduate from college, I knew how to appeal to his narcissism while avoiding anything that might set him off—although he no doubt unconsciously believed he was, as always, in charge of our affiliation, I was actually the one controlling the relationship. But about ten years after our reconciliation, it was my turn to bid adieu. Due to some twisted episode he had fabricated in his mind, he maniacally lashed out at me over the phone as though I were his mortal enemy. Soon afterward, I wrote him to announce I would no longer tolerate such abuse and, therefore, would not be in contact with him until he began to act like a father. Apparently that was a concession he has been unwilling—or unable—to make.
Two decades have passed since I dropped my poignant letter to my father in the mailbox. Today, I am married and have a seven-year-old son. Lately I have been contemplating extending an olive branch to my dad once more. No, not because I want my boy to meet his grandpa. Nor do I myself miss the man who impregnated my mother. Instead, it boils down to only one thing: I just want his money.
***
A few years ago, I learned through my godfather who was still in touch with my dad that he is worth over a million dollars. A high-school dropout, my father eventually went to trade school and became an electrician. Once he mastered the skill, he started his own business as an electrical commercial contractor. Throughout his career he not only performed all the duties associated with ownership—bidding jobs, purchasing materials, coordinating projects, and so on—he actually did the bulk of the day-to-day tasks as well. My father would often walk into a super-size building and singlehandedly lay the conduit, push through the wire, put in the light fixtures, assemble the giant fuse box that channeled all the power, and apply the finishing touches, such as plugs and covers, for the entire edifice. During his time as a blue-collar entrepreneur, he never hired more than one full-time employee, occasionally pulling temporary workers from the union hall (naturally, he hated unions) when he faced an especially daunting assignment. By owning and managing a large-scale operation while minimizing labor costs and running the company out of his house, he was able to accumulate significant wealth and retire young. If there is one trait I have always admired about my father, it is his amazing work ethic.
While my dad was forever motivated by the Almighty Dollar and what it could buy (“The only test of a man’s IQ is how much money he makes” he repeatedly reminded me), I have always searched for employment that I felt could bring me a sense of meaning regardless of whether it commanded an impressive salary. (I certainly wouldn’t have spent eight years pursuing a PhD and be currently serving as a college professor in the liberal arts at a small school if this weren’t the case.) Likewise, I have never been the type of person who seeks handouts or devilishly schemes ways of bilking people for personal gain. Yet here I am, today, devising a plan to suck up to my father until he dies (now 72-years-old and a three- to four-pack a day smoker for much of his life, he could take his last breath any day), for no other reason than to be included in his will.
Does this make me a scoundrel? Am I guilty of a tiny (or even large) measure of hypocrisy? I admit, I feel considerably sleazy when I entertain the idea of following through with the manipulative act of embracing my father while slipping my hand into the wallet in his back pocket. But then I ask myself, Why shouldn’t I? The least the guy could do, after a lifetime of meanness and neglect, is grant me an inheritance. Having alienated every family member except his also-aging, dysfunctionally timid second wife, who else will he leave money to—the good folks at the local Tea Party headquarters? (Always bigoted and a staunch conservative, his early political heroes included Barry Goldwater and George Wallace.) The Glenn Beck Memorial Fund? (An aunt once told me that one of my cousins, while visiting my father, was thrown out of his house for debating with him over a FOX News show.) An anti-immigration society? (Wouldn’t you know it, my father actually lives in the great state of Arizona—Sun City no less, a town in which security officers roam the grounds looking for signs of children because the little, noise-making bastards are not allowed to live there.)
The ultimate justification for my dubious undertaking, though, is that I don’t want the money for me but for my seven-year-old son. Truth be told, I wouldn’t even be thinking of contacting my father and re-establishing a relationship were it not for my boy. Should I be willed a tall stack of his bank notes, I would invest it and someday use the accumulated amount for my kid’s college education. And this time, there would be no need for my dear ol’ dad—busy nourishing maggots six feet below ground—to sign any paperwork.


Salon.com
Comments
Sorry you went through all that horror, and it sounds like your son is the beneficiary of the negative lessons you learned about fatherhood - how NOT to do it.
Beats me (so to speak) how people who are disciplined at their work can be assholes in their personal life...consistency, people, consistency! But a lot of people are 'good' at doing what they have to in their jobs and then letting it all hang out at home. It's a wonder any children grow up semi-sane...
Anyway, you've given us an alternative Father's Day view.
This is a very interesting question, and I don't know that there is a correct answer to it. In my opinion you and your son deserve it for the years of misery he put you through. But, as Myriad says above, there's a very good chance your efforts at reconciliation could all be for naught. Some people are just heartless and it sounds as if your dad may be one of them.
Thanks for your comments and making me a fav.
Would you let grandpa take his grandchild for the weekend?
You and your family are much better off with him out of your life!
This is truly a no-brainer...
Can you forgive yourself? Can you forgive him?
I had a situation with my father a few years back which was slightly similar. Nothing like the abuse you suffered, but after not speaking to him for years following an epic row, he started sending me a fat, monthly check just to help with expenses after I had my daughter. I barely managed a hello for 5 years, but I sure did cash those checks every month. He actually owed me at least some of the money, but I still look back on that time and feel a a twinge of regret. I made him suffer for his sins longer than I should have.
In your case, of course your son deserves that money, especially if he's giving it to some ridiculous "tea-party" charity, but then again, you are lucky to have freed yourself from his negative energy. The pursuit of his money just might bring you back into his darkness. Very tricky decision, but no one has a right to judge you. Do what you feel is right and live with it. What else can anyone say?
Some people, you know, live to a ripe old age despite what should be deadly smoking habits. Which could mean him living long enough to consume most or even all of his fortune during which time you will have felt obligated to care for him. Consider what hell this could become and tread carefully.
This is a piece you should have written after you played out your scheme. Your lack of patience certainly will cost you the money and could cost you your safety.
If he finds a way to hurt you one last time, in the end he will pay because it will be his last thought and he'll know himself truly in his last moment on earth. I'm very sorry your father was inadequate and inferior and his life dragged on to burden you with this for so long. I'm happy for your son you're not like him.
Put it to good use.
your dad is at an age when nothing will change anything. he will either leave you all his money or some of his money or none of his money, based on whatever is driving him, and that whatever is a big mystery.
he might have a new best friend, a girlfriend, a charity, a political cause. you could suck up to him every day until he dies and he could let you and possibly know why you're doing it and not leave you one blessed penny because he hates your guts for being a pandering scheming son of a bitch.
he may leave you the whole kaboodle without your doing anything.
if you meet up with him you are obligated to do two things:
1. either NOT tell him about your son, his grandson. in which case you become a liar and you will strain your relationships with your son and your wife, not to mention your father, who will, with the instincts of the devil, figure you're hiding something.
or 2. or protect your son, his grandson from his grandfather by never allowing the two to have a relationship. if you do that, not only won't you inherit one nickle, he'll hate you to his dying day for "depriving him of his blood" or some such shit. not because he really cares, but because he would enjoy having a good reason to hate your guts because that's what he's about.
so it's a lose lose situation since he never opened the door to you. you would have to open the door to him.
my advice: stay away from him. he is all bad things to you and always has been. he is not a force to be reckoned with. you don't have the equipment to deal with a psychopath. you have all kinds of emotional tethers. he's no less potent with age. he's just shorter and a wrinkly. but that brain is still in residence in his skull.
I think you know that.
plus if he knows about your son, he has two people to fuck with instead of just one.
if you subject your son to your father, you'll be repeating the same pattern. next generation.
you got away.
but did you?
You are not a kid and you can judge how much it will cost you to stay in touch with this old man. It's quite possible he will seem shrunken to you and you will wonder how this could even be the same guy who was the ogre of your youth. He might excite your pity. Or not.
Play it by ear. You did well in life without him and so will your son. But no reason why you should not have a share in his estate. Not because he owes you or you need it or for any other reason. Just because it is the normal thing for parents to leave their money to their kids. The only thing to avoid is putting up with crap in the hope of getting his money. Approach him with a "take or leave it" attitude. If he's decent to you, keep in touch. If he's still a jerk, turn your back. Good luck.
-with-Jesus, you can put in a claim. With the history, you might be able to (as they say in court) prevail, no matter what he says in his LW&T.
Touching, heart breaking story. You have every right to queue up for your share of his money, but don't. Reaching out to him would be an invitation to get your teeth kicked in. Again. He's a vile man, and age is not going to soften him. In fact, it is probably making him even more calcified and angry because despite all his money, he's still miserable. Thanks for sharing the hurt. It will probably be your only solace.
Your son might learn something about his dad (you).
For the money? Not so much.
Your best chance is if he dies intestate. In which case nothing you do matters.
Otherwise, there is a good chance he will have some sort of will/trust that will give it to his wife upon his death and you only get something when she dies.
I can only echo what others have said: Contacting him would open you and your son up to some very difficult stuff, and it is likely that his current spouse would get any money that is left at his death. A million bucks ain't what it used to be and could easily be eaten up by healthcare bills if he indeed dies a long slow death from cancer or emphysema.
Good luck.
That's the first thing I thought of. I don't know or care whether you are a scoundrel or not. But this seems like an awfully risky thing to do since your "target" is so unpredictable and prone to hostility. Wouldn't it make sense to call a lawyer first? I thought that children had a certain amount of right to inheritance and could contest the will if they weren't included. Maybe you have and just didn't mention it.
I think on some level you just want to get in touch with your father. I probably would in your place. It sounds like you have unfinished business. I don't know how or whether he'd be a threat to your own son, as others have suggested but I assume you know how to deal with it if he is.
Is it really worth it? Yes, that would be a lot of money, but it's a) a rumored amount of money; you have seen no financial accounts. b) a rumored amount of money, minus taxes, unknown debts, and divided amongst other heirs, some of whom after 20 years you may not know about.
But assuming it's a number you'd still be interested in and believe you could rely on getting, tell me, would you voluntarily expose your child to verbal or physical abuse for a million dollar pay day? Because if you reconcile, you may be doing just that.
Would you undo all the progress you made in your life undoing the damage that this man caused you for a million dollars? Because again, that may be part of the price you pay.
How much do you think a demanding narcissist could wring out of YOU, if he copped to the fact that you wanted his money? How easy would it be for him to get you to waste your time on him, take damage from him, and then give you nothing, just as he tried to do time and time before?
I think your life and your happiness and your child's emotional healthy are far too valuable to attempt a reconciliation of this kind, given the way you feel about the man, and given the low probability that you will end up getting any emotional or financial satisfaction out of the attempt. Best of luck in your decision.
Do not humiliate yourself in an attempt to get an inheritance from this man. You will only waste your time. I recall the reading of the will scene in "Mommie Dearest." That abusive parent continued her cruelty writing her children out of her will. That was why the author wrote the book, to make money badmouthing her mother, a famous actress. But the revenge was for naught, the woman was already dead. She wrote the book for the payday.
Again, I am sorry for your lost childhood. I am glad you and your mother survived.
Yes, money is always nice to have, and very useful, but in this case it's just not worth it. People used to tell me the same thing about money my mother offered me -- that I deserved it in exchange for what my childhood had been like -- but I just didn't feel good about it. In the end, as much as I often needed money, not having her money was the best thing.
I haven't seen, spoken or written to my mother in nearly 20 years and with luck, I never will again. Having my mother completely out of my life is like having a bad tooth pulled: it hurt when it happened, I'm always aware of the absence but I'm very glad it's gone.
Clean break -- no dad, no dad's money -- is what I advise.