All My Wife's Facebook Friends Are Men: Should I Be Worried?
I joined the 21st Century a few weeks ago and signed up for Facebook. While the Facebook software loaded up the names of friends it found in my AOL inbox, one in particular surprised me: my wife's. Hers was an invitation only page so I sent her a friends request. Days passed without a reply until I confronted her about it one day while she checked her e-mail.
"So I'm good enough to marry but not good enough to be your Facebook friend?"
"I never check my Facebook page."
I playfully took the mouse and clicked through several pages of spam until I spotted my Facebook request.
"Well, you can do it now. It'll only take a second."
She gave me that "don't tell me what to do" look only a wife can deliver then promised to get around to it later.
I waited a few more days and still nothing. At first, I didn't think much of it. She will go days without putting her laundry up until I get seeing a freshly laundered basket of clothes on the kitchen table and put her unmentionables away myself. Procrastinating in regards to my friends request seemed perfectly predictable.

But last week I decided to have a little fun at her expense. I typed "cute guy" into Google Images and created a fake Facebook profile for my chosen hunk. While my wife hogged the desktop, I sent her a friend request via my laptop. Guess what? Within minutes, she accepted my request!
While I snooped around her Facebook page, a few peculiarities caught my eye. First, no wedding pictures nor mention of her marital status. And secondly, all her Facebook friends were cute guys!
When I foolishly asked her why all of her friends had Y chromosomes, I naturally got my ass handed to me for sticking my nose in places it did not belong. She left in a huff this Sunday night, allegedly to buy fish food. Three hours later she came home empty-handed, which was not unexpected since all our pet stores close at 6 on the Sabbath.
I have yet to broach this topic again and am debating my next move. Personally I don't mind if she wants a little action on the side; it's the being lied to that I find unacceptable. She was still a virgin when we met so I imagine a little sexual curiosity about other guys is perfectly natural.
And if we're being frank, I feel at times like I retired from the dating game too early in life. Like Roger Clemens did numerous times, I've got that itch to play again. You see, dating is a lot like baseball. Each sport is cyclical: dead ball eras are soon followed by home run eras and back again. Unfortunately I began my own dating career during what we playboys refer to as the "blue ball" era. Guys remember the time well: both Clarence Thomas and Bill Clinton found themselves embroiled in sexual harassment suits while the Miller Brewing Company fired Jerold J. Mackenzie from his $95,000-per-year job for discussing a Seinfeld episode with a female co-worker.
While the frustrated baseball players of the early '90s began using performance enhancing drugs like Steroids and HGH to up their power numbers, we single men adopted our own dating enhancing drugs such as alcohol and roofies to up our own numbers.
While those around me indulged in the date rape era, I can proudly say every notch I carved unto my bedpost I came about honestly. I have never knowingly used dating enhancing drugs. Admittedly, I did take Paxil during the 1998 dating season--a drug that is now known to cause four hour erections in those who use it--but at the time a doctor had prescribed it for social anxiety disorder so I consider myself clean.
Now that I am married, our society has seemingly entered a sexual Shangrai-Lai. There is no longer a need to get a woman drunk or slip some Flunitrazepam into her drink if you want to get lucky. As Good Morning America puts it, "oral sex is the new good night kiss".
The language of infidelity is quickly fading into the past. A decade ago we used words like cheating, adultery and swinging to describe sex outside marriage, words that connote lies, hellfire and really bad aftershave respectively. But today? The broken marriage has been replaced by the open marriage. Every day more and more people are realizing monogamy is a medieval institution that breeds jealousy and possessiveness propped up by Republicans who don't even practice it as a campaign wedge issue to win themselves the votes of the Religious Right. Monogamy has outlived its usefulness in a modern society where the pill, abortion and DNA testing are all readily available.
Is polyamory--which dictionary.com defines as "participation in multiple and simultaneous loving or sexual relationships"--the wave of the future? For the good of mankind, I hope it is. Both my wife and myself had really let ourselves go during our first year of marriage. She put on some weight while I stopped working out, lost my muscle tone and began to bear an uncanny resemblance to Shaggy of Scooby Doo fame. Since my wife put up her Facebook page, she has started working out every day and watching what she eats. Meanwhile, I've actually shaved, cut my hair and joined my hometown gym. We both look and feel better already!
* * *
My wife and I did come to an understanding of sorts last night. She belatedly apologized for snapping at me while I told her it was alright, that she no longer had to hide anything from me and that love and understanding had replaced shame and guilt as the zeitgeist of our time.
Now if only I could get her to call it something other than fish food . . .


Salon.com
Comments
"But last week I decided to have a little fun at her expense. "
What you did was not "a little fun"...it was an attempt at entrapment and it worked.
My husband and I have all of each other's passwords.
Trust is trust and frankly your wife's behavior doesn't seem very trustworthy.
Good luck
rated
It's like if someone doesn't know what it means to be a soldier, then he's also not going to understand why he shouldn't throw down his weapon and run away at the first approach of the enemy.
This reminds me of a guy who called into a radio talk show I heard about thirty years ago. He stated, in true deadpan fashion, that he had just bought his wife one of those new pulsating shower heads mounted on a hose. He noted that she must be enjoying it because she was always in the shower and he could hear the thing pulsing away. But he was confused and wondered “What the hell is she doing in there?”
Good luck with all that. Your wife is definitely being sneaky and didn't want you to see her Facebook. However, now that you sent a request as a "fake" person, you're guilty of being sneaky too.
I wish you the best of luck getting back on the same wavelength with your lady, and I hope you blog about the results of your conversations. I'm fascinated. Rated and Favorited. :o)
She calls us over to check it out all the time. Her husband hurt himself last night. Laughed himself right off the chair.
For some reason "online doesn't count" with a lot of people.
Maybe she calls it fish food, because she is black widowing... and dumping the bodies Hoffa style...
Traigus: Liked the Hoffa line. Funny stuff!
And thanks to everyone else who commented.
(The traditional way usually involving trial separations and divorce courts all in our insane quest to safeguard the genitals of our spouses. Is there honestly anyone out there who really believes we're "wired" as a species to be monogamous for life?)
So your wife never had sex with anyone else and now she's curious about other men. Will wonders never cease! Who would have ever thought that would be a possibility?
(Oh, and you really knew a "lot" of people into the date rape scene? That's really creepy. I know plenty of people, but I don't believe any of them ever drugged a woman to get her into bed. I think learning that about a person would be enough to make me never want to spend time with them again. In fact, I know it.)
Rated.
"My husband and I have all of each other's passwords."
My wife and I do, too. In fact, if I'm too lazy to log into an email account I'll ask her or my partner to do it for me.
We all know each other's passwords. We have very little need for privacy, see, because we hold nothing back from one another. There's nothing I've ever written anyone that I couldn't easily explain to my lover(s) - so why would I care if they have access to my email accounts, social networking sites, etc?
I think trusting somebody to be inside your body but not trusting them with your email password is just a little... odd. Then again, I have odd views.
I have always liked a little mystery in my relationships and have absolutely no desire to know every little detail about my husband's life, or he, mine. It makes things more interesting.
rated.
It is probably more accurate that we are best made for serial monogomy. There is some evidence now that a four and seven year itch is a real biological event.
In the modern world, as much as we might want to change how we feel, we are still animals, with brains meant for a wild world. Mate guarding behavior (jealousy) is perfectly natural and polyamory rarely works.
And lets for a minute mention the value of keeping your word. You and she made a promise, I assume, to be faithful to one and other. Are you intending to break your promise because she broke hers?
What is a marriage without sexual fidelity? It is a business partnership for your personal life. You agree to split the bills, to take care of each other's personal debt, when they are indisposed to make decisions on their behalf - just like a business partner. Now I'm not opposed to having a marriage like that, an agreement from the beginning to have a marriage that way but you should do it from the beginning of the relationship - not in the middle.
I assume you have an investment in the relationship. Do you really want to dillute your investment by including a third and fourth person in the mix?
"Mate guarding behavior (jealousy) is perfectly natural and polyamory rarely works."
And you base this statement on what, exactly? Your broad statistical analysis of polyamorous families that you have studied in detail over the years?
I know many poly relationships that work quite well.
I could just as easily say, "Mate guarding behavior (jealousy) is outdated and unnecessary any longer in our society, and polyamory usually works."
How could you claim I was wrong? What facts, figures, and observational analysis would you pull out to prove me incorrect?
Ah, right. You couldn't. There is no data on polyamorous families in our time and culture; or precious little, and I am willing to bet you can count the number of "poly" people you know on one hand, if you know any at all.
Why not talk to me? I've been in a 10 year long poly marriage, it works, we're happy, and I could introduce you to dozens like us. But that wouldn't fit neatly with your already decided world view, would it?
Like kids who always think they know better than their parents and who rarely do, this generation seems bent on redefining men and women's relationships with each other. But, we find that those wise generations before us knew what they were doing in this area. We humans are weak, and even if you're not, the other person will be. So, in understanding that DON'T FLIRT WITH DANGER. There's a reason men and women used to work apart from each other, and there's a reason why most affairs now happen with someone in the work place, because we've breeched that sexual line. I'm not arguing that we go back to a place of inequality, but I am suggesting that once we're married we stick with friends of the same sex. It's effective, it's smart, it's respectful of your spouse, and IT'S SAFE. Otherwise, you're just flirting with the cliff.
We can pretend all we want that we're enlightened and don't need those traditional norms, but who are we kidding?
http://www.bostonmagazine.com/articles/till_death_do_us_pay/
Perhaps this is a good time to pull the eject chord?
By your logic, nobody should ever get married, because even the most traditional marriages can end in divorce and alimony payments.
Come to think of it. Mine could too.
I have no problem with polyamory on moral or biological grounds. Couples can strike whatever bargain they like regarding fidelity. But it is something of a logistical challenge to have more than one amorous relationship.
If thus isn't a giant yank on our collective OS leg, my first thought is don't kid yourself. Your wife is courting and having relationships with other men behind your back. If you're cool with that, fine. If not, you might want to do something about it.
You are correct sir. No one should get married in this day and age. Not only because of the reasons that Travis D'Arby describes in his main post above, but also because of the legal changes in family law that have transpired over the last 35 years. In fact when you sign the marriage contract nowadays what you are signing is a very different body of law. So different that we can call it "Marriage 2.0", instead of just the "marriage" that your parents, your grandparents, or anyone before ever knew.
Why do you think this hidden thing became known?
You know the answer, you just need to be honest with yourself.
"There's a reason men and women used to work apart from each other, and there's a reason why most affairs now happen with someone in the work place, because we've breeched that sexual line. I'm not arguing that we go back to a place of inequality, but I am suggesting that once we're married we stick with friends of the same sex. It's effective, it's smart, it's respectful of your spouse, and IT'S SAFE. Otherwise, you're just flirting with the cliff."
So, what you can't go to the store, or talk to your neighbors, because they might seduce you?
Bad things can happen in this world, but you're expressing extreme paranoia!
Tell your wife to buy herself a sexy new dress and high heels, get a mani and pedi, her hair done...whatever...and take her someplace she would never imagine and give her the fantasy date she craves. It's what she wants. And she wants it with YOU! Mama knows!
When individuals do not approach marriage as a project of teamwork and cooperation, it is doomed to failure.
This may mean the involvement of other people or not. This may mean a division of labor and contribution that is not traditional in one or more of the project's companions.
When the goals of the members of the team are making the team thrive, the team will thrive. When the goals of the members of the team are making the individual members thrive, then the team will break up.
I am sure that you can think of many rock bands and team projects that have thrived or died under these circumstances.
Know your own goals, boundaries, limits, needs, and wants, and communicate these clearly. Otherwise you are not going to make any partnership work.
Rated
There IS a reason the unknown has become known and she's right....you already know why.
It sounds like you're fine with where you've come, though some people here might question that. I say if you're happy with the arrangement and your communication-level with your wife, if it feels good, do it! My only question is, How will you feel if she leaves you? Or, what's the worst thing for you that could come out of this?
I'm not sure what the questioners are getting at, precisely, but my anxiety here is hoping both you and your wife share the same view of polyamory, rather than one of you view it as an expansion of trust and the other view it as a kinky phase until another, supposedly better-suited monogamist is found.
Well-written and fascinating video! (Though my daughter may not thank you when I link it on her FB wall. Perhaps I should ask her if she'd rather me make a fake page to link it on her fake page, which she confessed she was bad, bad for doing in terms of games and I just held up my hand: Too mindboggling; you know I don't do apps!) Thanks for sharing this!
Swinging usually means that both parties in the marriage are aware of each others behavior and both just crave a little bit of sexual variety. This is not a bad thing as long as everyone is okay with it.
A polyamorous relationship is a when three or more people have a relationship with each other, ALL of them, TOGETHER. Now these relationships tend to not work out, but only because you actually have to work to maintain three different relationships COEXISTING and intermingling. It takes a lot of work to keep one relationship between two people working and healthy - imagine maintaining three at the same time! But let me tell you when you do see a working poly relationship it is an absolutely beautiful thing!
Have a bunch of relationships completely separate from one another - even if they know about each other - seems, to me, like a recipe for building resentment and jealousy because your wife doesn't know what is going on with the other girl. And the other girl doesn't know what's going on with the wife, etc. I just don't see that working out so well.
I have a huge issue with people saying you can't have friends with the opposite sex if you're married. I am a woman and I studied physics in college where there aren't many girls. I have ALWAYS had an easier time getting along with guys than girls. Not to say I don't have any girlfriends, but the vast majority of my friends are guys and it has always been that way. I refuse to sacrifice them. If feelings do pop up (and I will admit that this has happened once) then you may need to break off the friendship. You basically say to the other person, "I know this is unfair to you, but I have made this promise to another and I really love him and I don't want to lose him. To make sure I'm not tempted I need to back off." And the guy in question, who cared about me, understood and respected this even if he didn't like it. And my fiance knows about it all. That's how you honor your commitments and promise. It isn't an issue because we trust one another.
You would do well to really, and I mean really, study the science of female attraction. From this article it is clear your wife neither admires you or respects you, nor does she seem particularly turned on by you. It is easy to see why, since straight women are biologically hard-wired to be attracted to men, but not just any man -- a high status man: a man who is admired, who leads, who is desired by others, and you are acting like the lowest status of man, if you are even acting like a man at all.
It hurts to watch.
Please don't be insulted by this. Until now, it is not your fault. It is the culture we live in. Being a man can get you in a lot of trouble, and you've been raised by your mothers and sisters and hollywood and television to be the nice guy that none of these women are attracted to but need to depend on anyway. You've opted for the safe route, and look where you ended up? Life rewards risk takers, my brother. Time to start taking some calculated gambles. Start by kicking your wife out on the street, and macking on her sister.
Just thought I'd notify you in case you haven't already learned, that you have been nominated for Beta of the Month over at Roissy In DC -- a popular blog. Given the other candidates, you are an easy winner.
http://roissy.wordpress.com/2009/08/07/july-2009-beta-of-the-month/
You would do well to read Roissy's blog from front to back as well as the regular blogs in that general genre. Critically, of course. I don't mean to endorse 100% of what is written there, but you are doing a pretty good job of being a walking endorsement of that general worldview already. Might as well synthesize it with your own where possible, and you will definitely come out richer for doing so.
You are clearly being played like a fiddle here and your reaction to the situation is an embarrassment to anybody with a drop of testosterone in their blood. Fix this quick.
JS
http://roissy.wordpress.com/2009/08/07/july-2009-beta-of-the-month/#comments
Lots of interesting comments, and a few asinine ones (as usual). I've read it through twice, and I've thought about it a lot as I am in a similar, yet totally different situation.
I love my man. He loves me. He's my youngest daughter's dad (though not the sperm donor) and they love each other utterly. We get along well, we have great conversation and are very honest with each other.
He claims he has ED, but he won't get anything done about it, plus I know that he always could get hard and FAST when with someone new and exciting--so it's not physical. I'm not going into detail, but lets say I have some deformity, and it's no wonder that he finds it difficult to perform when I'm in the room. Sex has become "the Man Show"--all about whether he'll be able to this time.
So I recently approached him, explaining that I am aware of all of that, and that I think he should know that I wouldn't blame him a bit if he decided to have sex with someone else.
There is nothing lonelier for me than having sex with someone who can't treat it as anything but a job or an obligation. It's death of the soul. Somebody around here should be having sex.
Beta male, my ass. Whatever works for the two of you, it's nobody else's call.
I am saddened that you may be in a marriage too soon in your life. I married in my mid thirties, after trying out a career girl lifestyle, a party girl lifestyle, living on both coasts AND living abroad. I was ready to enjoy life with great one man when I married. It's important to try to live life first before marrying, and before having kids. That way there aren't regrets for missing out...
I dont think your wife has levelled with you and agree with you that honesty is a problem. if you guys want to renegotiate an open marriage, then you've gotta get it all out on the table.
Im a big polyamory wannabe.. some thoughts on it in my blog..
I think you may be overestimating its impact. it appears to me that still only a tiny minority of ppl in this country actually practice polyamory. and women are naturally disinclined to nonmonogamy.