Travis D'arby's Links

Salon.com
JULY 29, 2009 10:23AM

Great Moments in MILF History: From Cher to Diane Keaton

Rate: 8 Flag

Imagine a 50 year-old woman seducing a 32 year-old man. Fifty years ago, the woman would have been portrayed as a faded movie star, her advances would be spurned and the scene would prove just how pathetic and out of touch she was, as it did in the Oscar-winning 1950 drama Sunset Boulevard.

But today?  It's just another episode in the life of Alex Rodriguez, the 32 year-old slugger who left his gorgeous young wife last year for a fling with a 50 year-old pop star.

A-Rod and Madonna

Instead of being creeped out by Alex going for a woman old enough to be his mother, we fans wished we could be him.  After all, what man wouldn't want to find out exactly which kind of acrobatic positions the Kabbalah enthusiast Madonna could contort herself into?

So when did Really Legal replace Barely Legal as the sexual fantasy of choice for the discerning male?

The transformation has been a long time coming and closely mirrors the development of indie rock. Much like the Velvet Underground and MC5 began their musical odysseys as reactions against the prefabricated bubblegum pop groups of the '60s like the Archies and the Monkees, the MILF movement began in the late '60s as a protest against such manufactured Hollywood sex symbols as Raquel Welch and Jane Fonda.  The final insult was the 1967 film The Graduate, a movie as insulting to fans of MILF as the Archies hit Sugar, Sugar was to fans of good music. This mean-spirited propaganda piece portrayed Mrs. Robinson not as every schoolboy's fantasy, but instead as our worst nightmare.  

050610_hampson_graduate_hmed_9ahmedium

Four years later, Rod Stewart courageously sang of his love for an older woman in his hit Maggie May. The song delicately chronicled the love a teenager felt for his middle-aged lover and gave a voice to our closeted yearnings: "The morning sun when its in your face really shows your age; But that don't worry me none in my eyes you're everything."

Later that same year, the Hal Ashby film Harold and Maude brought the May-December romance to the big screen, as the suicidal teenager Harold finds both the love of his life and a reason for living in the 80 year-old Maude.

harold-and-maude-kiss

The next twenty years proved a fallow time for both indie rock and the MILF. While disco and then hair metal dominated the charts, young starlets like Farrah Fawcett, Brooke Shields and Tawny Kitaen dominated television, movies and music videos respectively.  The MILF movement appeared to have gone the way of the pet rock and the CB radio, a '70s fad that no one felt comfortable owning up to in public.

It would take a mythic figure to reverse the tide of corporate rock and feathered hair. 

Luckily two such figures arose like a pair of phoenixes out of the ashes of '80s excess.

Their names? 

Cher and Kurt Cobain.

While everyone knows the success of Nirvana's Nevermind CD slayed hair metal and ushered in the grunge era, Cher's contribution to the MILF movement is a story that has yet to be told.

Flash back to the late '80s.  Hollywood's hottest young hunks like Tom Cruise, Val Kilmer and Bon Jovi guitarist Richie Sambora mysteriously swore off the teenage poontang to rock under the sheets with the forty-something Cher.  At the time, this blew my teenage mind. Cher was like old enough to be their mother.  What could these young hunks possibly see in her?  To be frank, it grossed me out. And then the If I Could Turn Back Time video came out and I saw two cheeky reasons why these guys chose Cher over her younger contemporaries like Paula Abdul and Janet Jackson.

Both this new sound and this new lust that Nirvana and Cher each respectively brought to the mainstream needed a name.  Initially music critics settled on indie rock, but with acts like Nirvana, Smashing Pumpkins and Soundgarden all signed to major labels, the irony proved too much, and  the original label soon gave way to grunge and then the catch-all of alternative rock.

Meanwhile the lust for women old enough to be one's mother remained a love that dared not speak its name, mainly because it lacked a name.  That is, until 1995 when the term MILF first appeared on an alt.mag.playboy USENET post. The term went viral thanks to the 1999 film American Pie and today refers to any attractive woman in the 35-50 age range. An actual brood of whining children is not required.
 
While Cher blew her status as a MILF with a series of embarrassing infomercials and box office flops like Faithful, Kurt Cobain one-upped her by not only blowing his career but also his brains out, effectively putting an end to grunge as we knew it.
 
With Nirvana and Cher no longer in the picture, the late '90s gave way to glorified bar bands like Hootie and the Blowfish and Train.  Old was out and pop ingenues such as Britney Spears and Christina Aguliera became our new sex symbols.  Intolerance spread across the land and the courts tore us apart from the women we loved.  This open hatred culminated in the greatest travesty of justice since the Rodney King verdict: the August 7, 1997 sentencing of sixth grade teacher Mary Kay Letourneau for the bogus statutory rape of her student Vili Fualaau. True love always finds a way in the end though and after serving several years in prison, Ms. Letourneau finally got to marry the love of her life Mr. Fualaau on May 20, 2005.  Imagine Romeo & Juliet with a happy ending and you have these two beautiful lovebirds.
 
MaryKay
 
Only a madman would come out of the closet during such a hostile time and that madman was me. My parents kicked me out of the house for dating a woman 18 years my senior. At the time, I would never have predicted these two counterculture movements would both take over the mainstream a few short years later.

But take over they both did.  The line between alternative and mainstream rock became increasingly blurred, with the biggest bands of the era such as Creed, Nickelback and Daughtry all paying tribute to the sound of alt-rock gods like Pearl Jam and Alice in Chains with their every hit single.

And while I cowardly hid in the closet and let people think my girlfriend was in fact my mother, a man much bolder than I strode like a Colossus onto the MILF scene.  Ashton Kutcher: you are our Martin Luther King Jr. and your glowing tweets about the glory that is Demi Moore's ass are our movement's Letter From the Birmingham Jail.
 
ashton_moore_hmed3p
 
Ashton courageously opened the floodgates to a new era of MILF pride--the only thing missing are the parades. Taboos were broken as  fifty-four year old Kathy Bates bared it all in About Schmidt.  The following year, in a performance so convincing he couldn't possibly have been acting, the usually wooden Keanu Reeves showed off his charm as he courted the fifty-seven year old Diane Keaton in Something's Gotta Give.
 
Whether it be the 2003  Fountains of Wayne hit Stacy's Mom or this May's Justin Timberlake/Andy Samberg collaboration Mother Lover, the MILF movement has also sparked some of this decade's greatest musical moments. 
 
Justin Timberlake/Andy Samberg -- "Mother Lover" Music Video
 
 
Every decade must have its moniker, from the roaring '20s to the swinging '60s. If the '80s were the Me Decade, it seems only fitting  to call the aughts the MILF Decade.
 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Youth is wasted on the young, and a well maintained elder has the benefit of both. At 50 I have no interest in trying to shallow dive into the kiddie pool. I do NOT want to have to learn a new set of cultural references, NOR do I want another child.
Great post - very, very enlightening! I would never have put those pieces together, but now - I think you're onto something here!
My wife is two years older than me and that in itself back when we got married was strange to all those I know. Maybe it's because I was a bit more "mature" than most of the guys her age (as my wife claims) and maybe since men have been doing this since the beginning of time, it's the woman's time to go for the young and hot.

Demi and Ashton seem happy together. The Madonna/A-Rod thing was just a fling, nothing more. If Anna Nicole Smith can marry a 90-year old man, I think a 50 year old woman should be able to date a 32-year old any day.

I get the humor of your post and it made me laugh. I just wanted to take time out to laugh at the double standard. It has always amazed me. If I were single, I could see dating someone close to my age, or my age, or older, but not extremely young. I could not handle that at all.
Travis D’arby wrote: “When did older women transcend the stereotype of the wrinkly old hag and transform themselves into the modern day sex symbols known affectionately as MILF?”

Damn, dude! Male chauvinist pig much?

Did it ever occur to you that the women you are snerking at in your post might actually have something to bring to a relationship besides their bodies and their looks? Do you “get” that the term Mother’s I’d Like to Fuck (MILF) is itself degrading and insulting to women because it reduces them to “things” verses living, breathing, intelligent human beings who have a value, besides being something you can use as a sex toy?

BTW, Mary Kay Letourneau is a convicted pedophile. Regardless of gender, any 35 year old ADULT that has sex with a 12 year old CHILD is a criminal.
KOB wrote: "If I were single, I could see dating someone close to my age, or my age, or older, but not extremely young. I could not handle that at all."

This is actually part one of a trilogy. Part two will describe why young men are attracted to older women as well as chronicle the dangers of dating younger women. The tragic case of Steve McNair is Exhibit A.

Owl: Thanks! I was surprised at how easily the indie rock/MILF connection worked.

Gwool: You make some good points which I will elaborate upon in part 2.

Safe_Bet: I'll answer you later.
Gwool makes a wonderful point, so does Blue.

The first time I ever heard of "MILF" was when I watched "Amercian pie"

Wolves on the graying side, ROCK! (God, I love men!)
"Did it ever occur to you that the women you are snerking at in your post might actually have something to bring to a relationship besides their bodies and their looks?"

I'm not snerking at anyone. I sincerely find older women attractive. This post is a tribute, not snark on my part. In part II, I will focus more on the personalities of MILF than simply their bodies.
I, just, lust for Diane!!!

Here's a movie (NOT with Diane) that I found extraordinary and intriguing:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0976051/
Objections in comments noted, but I loved: "Ashton Kutcher: you are our Martin Luther King Jr. and your glowing tweets about the glory that is Demi Moore's ass are our movement's Letter From the Birmingham Jail."

BTW, Anne Bancroft was only a few years older than Dustin Hoffman. She played way above her age, and he played below his for The Graduate.