Watching the Destruction, When Japan is “Home”
Tonight I feel almost unbearably sad. The post-tsunami photos I saw an hour ago on the internet from Western news sources showed bodies: Japanese children and adults, small hands and feet emerging from the rubble.
I always thought that a horrific natural disaster would make me feel, after 20+ years in Japan, like a foreigner, and that I desperately would need to get back “home” to the US. This disaster did not destroy my home or threaten my family here in Kobe, but it unexpectedly illuminated where “home” is in my heart.
The cold facts are hard enough: we experienced the strongest earthquake on record for Japan, with a magnitude of 9.0, a tsunami which rose to heights of 10 meters (40 feet) at some points, washing away entire communities, and multiple explosions at nuclear reactors in danger of complete meltdown. There are likely tens of thousands dead, and even after four days, many “survivors” are stranded without having food, water, or heat since the quake struck. Tohoku is very, very cold in this season.
I am not saying that there hasn’t been an outpouring of kindness and concern from old friends and family in the US; there has been. I’ve received so many Facebook messages, some from high school classmates I haven’t had contact with in decades, all wanting to make sure I was OK. My parents and siblings have called, and all expressed concerned about my Japanese husband’s family, wondering if they were affected by the quake and tsunami. I’ve had so many messages of thoughts and prayers going out for the people of Japan, all heartfelt and sincerely meant.
Yet, for all the kindness, there is a difference, a natural distance: most people knew little about Japan. This showed up in so many ways: early newscasts whose only point of Japanese reference was Tokyo, no matter how distant from the location in question, the misidentification of places shown in disaster scenes, the insistence on calling prefectures “states,” or frightening ignorance, like the CNN announcer who was certain that the meltdown in the nuclear reactor was influenced by the weather. I’ve heard people comment that the video footage looked like a Hollywood movie, or people who compared the scenes to Monopoly boards. They are not cold or uncaring, they are just looking at someone else’s tragedy, not their own.

In fact, the earthquake’s epicenter was far to the north of my home in Kobe, and physically, we are not suffering here. In Osaka where I was when it struck, I felt the tremor only slightly, as if I had a short bout of vertigo. No buildings here were destroyed, no people here dead, not even a bookshelf toppled. Yet when I watched video of the tsunami rushing inland in Miyagi-ken a few hours later, I felt horror stronger than any I have ever felt before. I saw the black wall of water rushing over the type of farms that surrounded me for many years, inundating homes like those of close friends, toppling the types of buildings I have lived and worked in. I knew instantly that there were going to be many, many people dead.
I spent yesterday and today talking to my colleagues and Japanese trainees, many of whom survived the 1995 Great Hanshin Earthquake that killed more than 6,400 and destroyed 200,000 buildings, though it was much weaker (magnitude 7.2) than this recent quake. The train station I use every day was destroyed in that quake, the highway I once lived beside had been twisted and toppled, and so many people here had their homes destroyed. The people of Kobe understand what the people of Tohoku are going through.


(1995 Great Hanshin Earthquake--Kobe)
Those places, the devastation, and the dead shown so graphically on t.v in the past days--these people are real to my heart, not just my head. These are places I have visited. Maybe they are people I have talked to, or family members of my students and colleagues. When the earthquake happened, I was in a two-day company-wide meeting in Osaka. Many of my colleagues were here in Osaka from Tokyo. One of my colleagues had lived in Sendai (Miyagi Prefecture), and is married to a woman from there, and on that day he still did not have any word on his in-laws who still live there.

Another colleague who lives in Ibaraki Prefecture got a panicked call from his Japanese wife who said that a bridge near their house had collapsed with people who had been on it had died. Another of my colleagues lived in Sendai for several years; he is stuck not knowing if old friends are dead or alive. One of my closest friends in Japan lived in Iwaki City, Fukushima Prefecture (where the nuclear reactors in question and site of terrible devastation from the tsunami) for three years. She has many friends there--she used to go running on the beaches where the tsunami hit. The father the host family she had lived with worked in the nuclear power plant.

For me, when I see the footage of the wreckage, for example, of the trains swept away in the tsunami, I know that I might have once ridden on that train line. When I see the footage of the cars trying to escape the oncoming tsunami, I remember driving roads that looked the same, over rice fields that looked like those, in cars that looked like the ones that remind you of Monopoly pieces. I look at the wreckage of Sendai and think of the little restaurant I ate at in Sendai a year ago, or wonder if the hotels I stayed at still exist, or if the people I had met on my last business trip to Tohoku in December are still alive.

People from the US, and from around the world, have shown so much support and kindness and compassion to Japan, and desire to help those who are in such desperate straits in Tohoku. Yet part of me feels like it is the subtle difference between watching a neighbor’s house burn down, and watching your own go up in flames.

One of my high school teachers wrote to me. She said
Good to hear that you and yours are OK. Many prayers and kind thoughts are in the works for your country. Stay safe.
I realized, just then, that she had said what I never really understood: this is my home, and this is my country now, and these are my people. In this moment that I ache unbearably for the countless dead, I am thankful for this tiny, unexpected gift, of finally understanding that I really am at home.
(2009 in the Tohoku Region--not far from the current disaster)


Salon.com
Comments
[Giant hugs]
I think whenever unimaginable tragedy strikes, we struggle with how to react, what to say, how to comprehend, and how to report/watch. I remember being horrified by some of the scenes shot and shown during Katrina, and the way the media played footage of people leaping off the twin towers...over and over and over and over. As though those people weren't somebody's husband, wife, sister, brother, son, daughter.
On a personal note, I've visited you and your country three times and the last decade, and I want you to know those won't be the last. I love the Japanese people. I love the mountains, the tiny villages, the cities. Everything in between.
Words can't express the horror of watching what's happening, even now.
I can fully relate to this. I had moved to New Orleans only one week prior to Hurricane Katrina. I am (was) a West Coast girl, and was not overly enthusiastic about moving to the South prior to and during my move (I moved for career reasons). But when I saw the images of my newly-adopted city underwater, and people who could I could have crossed paths with struggling to survive, and saw the passion and determination amongst the dispersed residents to return and rebuild, I fell in love. I became a New Orleanian in that moment.
I wish the best to you, your friends and family, and your country - my heart is with all of you. ~r
Harry's Ghost, you are so right, it is utterly overwhelming. Knowing other people are thinking of us here means a lot.
Verbal, yeah, I never thought when I headed out to Chiba in 1990 that I would still be here now. I am glad you have come to Japan, several times, and understand deeply the love I have for this place.
Just Thinking, much appreciated.
NOLA, I so understand what you are saying about New Orleans. Sometimes your heart chooses for you.
♥R
But I have no more "feeling" for it than any other western gaijin who's never been there. How could I?
But watching, reading, hearing about this devastation, I can relate. I lived in Santa Cruz, CA, for 12 years--it's essentially my home town. I was there for a devastating flood in the the winter of 1982; I was there for the Loma Prieta quake of 1989, when my 45 minute commute suddenly became a 2.5 hour slog up to Half Moon Bay and over a completely different road. My possessions were smashed; my house damaged; my downtown demolished, crushing people I knew under the weight of its unquakeproofed bricks and mortar. And it has never really recovered.
So I look at these photos, photos of beach towns that, aside from styles of cars and house, aside from Kanji on the signs, could be any one of hundreds of American beach towns, including my beloved Santa Cruz, and I can imagine, oh so easily, it being me. Because it was. It was my favorite stores getting destroyed, my friends' houses collapsing, the entire tenor of my town changing in a few short seconds.
I know nothing of Miyagi Prefecture except that Yoko Kanno comes from there. But I know beach towns. I know natural disasters. I have lived them. I have seen what Rita did to my parents' house in Lake Charles, LA; I have seen what hurricanes have done to my cousin Billy's Cape Cod town of Yarmouthport; and I have seen my beloved home town shaken by the hand of God.
I don't know you, Japan, but I feel for you. And wish you nothing but the best.
I also saw how people from other places struggled and couldn't get it right when describing what happened. When it's a place that you have experienced and know yourself, that's now undergone such terrible destruction, it's terribly frustrating to hear it described incorrectly. Although people are simply ignorant and generally doing the best they can, it feels like an insult added to an injury.
My prayers to you and the people of Japan for their continued safety, and for the long recovery in the weeks and months and years to come.
Douglas--Thanks for your well-considered and thoughtful response. You said "But I have no more "feeling" for it than any other western gaijin who's never been there. How could I?" Yet everything you wrote shows you have profound sympathy for the people of Tohoku, and empathy through your hardships in Santa Cruz. I wasn't trying to imply that compassion is the sole province of people who are native to a location--that was not my intention. Your thoughtful comments, and others as well, show deep caring, and profound empathy for people, though they are far away.
FusunA, Algis, tg within--thank you for reading and commenting on my post, and for your thoughts and caring.
Ixxidust--you caught just exactly my feeling in some of those moments of listening to other people explain. Thank you for the thoughts and prayers--as you know, recovery will take a long time.
When we first confirmed that he would be able to reach Narita and get home, I wrote this letter to friends and family. These events have reminded me that once had a second home, a land and a people I would never have left if civil war had not made my tall gringa-presence a red-flag danger for friends and colleagues, many many of them numbered among the tens of thousands of victims of our country's pursuit of so-called rebels.
So many kinds of disaster... some natural... some not... so many kinds of rebellion. Which "disaster" will finally call us ALL to remember that we are one human family.
I share my 'family update' written after confirming our son's flight "out" this past Sunday afternoon, which already feels somehow very long ago. Thank you again, Ellen.
I now have a vivid sense of what my own parents must have experienced when they didn't hear from me during the mid-1970's temblor that took more than 23,000 lives in Guatemala. The quake happened while I was up on a long-term indigenous language experimental study stay in an extremely isolated mountain location with spotty "western union telegram" service which, whenever it was out (often), didn't raise alarm. I only learned about the earthquake when, 3-or-4 days after it struck, a fellow volunteer finally found me and brought me off the mountain to telegram my folks. They already had tickets to Washington DC; I was the only Peace Corps volunteer "missing" in the disaster. We were all safe, and everyone was re-assigned to unforgettable disaster relief duty for at least a month.
Today, it's like there's almost no comparison between the evolving disaster in Japan and the tragic death toll and physical impact of that Latin American event, so many decades ago, which occurred in what we casually termed back then a "third world country" consisting widely of adobe or wood-slat dwellings with corrugated-metal or tile roofs ; entire villages were simply buried in the mudslides that roared down the exotic-woods-lumber-industry-deforested-and-eroded mountainsides.
Guatemala's mid-70's tragedy unfolded so differently from Japan's today, where almost unbelievably well-prepared, well-constructed, and well-planned protections -- even in the midst of so much suffering and devastation -- still are operating to protect untold numbers of people and communities from experiencing far worse impacts. It is nothing short of miraculous.
There's just no comparison -- unless it is happening to someone you know. There IS no comparison -- when it is.
This has changed the lives of our friends forever. This is a harrowing experience, one which they are meeting with truly heroic courage and hope.
Events continue to evolve; news unfolds in many different venues, and I try to stay on top of what's actually happening and sort the catastrophic from the hyperbolic, as best I can from this distance. I suspect that poor C-- will rue his mother's digital perturbations; but that, I suppose, is just my boomer-generation response to the perennial you-tube posting updates of a happier, younger tide...
May this tide of human caring and compassion carry peaceful and healthful gifts to Japan's shores, very soon.
Thank you for your support and expressions of concern to us and to those continuing to suffer in Japan.
Bless you all.