Verbal Remedy AKA Denise

Verbal Remedy AKA Denise
Location
Del Mar, California, The One That's In A State Of Steep Decline
Birthday
January 18
Title
Columnist, http://www.doesthismakesense.com
Company
Much preferred to the alternative.
Bio
Born. Grew up. Kept growing up. Started growing older. Still at both the growing up and growing older. Stay tuned.

MY RECENT POSTS

Verbal Remedy AKA Denise's Links

Just For Fun(ny)
Opinionated Much?
Personal/Memoir
Food Posts
Entertainment
Archive of OS Games/Memes
MAY 9, 2009 4:08PM

A Tale of Two Mothers

Rate: 54 Flag

 (If you haven't yet found your way to Mothership's account of her 9 month ordeal a pregnant unwed teen in 1967, do check it out.)

 

Everything I Knew About Myself: 1968-1989

The sum total of information given to my parents on the day they picked me up from Catholic Social Services was a simple list of my birthweight, length, and nationality (Belgian-English-Irish, the document said, although actually it turned out to be Dutch rather than Belgian).

Oh, and, Dad told me years later, somebody mentioned that I might be artistic. Because my birthmother was.

That's really all anybody needs to know about their brand spanking new baby, isn't it? Here you go, Mom and Dad--your bundle of joy, a tabula rasa, no history, no heritage. Yours and yours alone. Go forth and raise it up right.


At last the large egg broke, and a young one crept forth crying, “Peep, peep.” It was very large and ugly. The duck stared at it and exclaimed, “It is very large and not at all like the others. I wonder if it really is a turkey. We shall soon find it out, however when we go to the water. It must go in, if I have to push it myself.”    

9780688159320 


I grew up pale Irish and freckled in a town full of dark-eyed, dark-haired, even-pigmented Eastern Europeans. Surrounded by Kovacs and Novaks and Hudachkos and Tutkos and Palaschaks and a hundred other kinds of other -kos and -aks, I stood out. Couldn't help but.

The benchmark of beauty where I grew up was dark. Athletic. Sturdy. The benchmark of human worth was physical prowess--how fast you could run, how high you could jump, how far you could hit, how many pieces you could turn out in a shift on the assembly line. 

Me: none of the above. 

No, I was a misfit. Imaginative, daydreamy, distractible, uncoordinated, wimpy, artistic, bookish from a very young age.

 

P5080003

 

First birthday: Mom and Dad and the Italian side of the family. Grandma, on whose lap I sit, just just turned 91. Grandpa Joe, behind Mom, lived to be 104 and essentially died of boredom.


“Oh,” said the mother, “that is not a turkey; how well he uses his legs, and how upright he holds himself! He is my own child, and he is not so very ugly after all if you look at him properly.

“...he is not pretty; but he has a very good disposition, and swims as well or even better than the others. I think he will grow up pretty, and perhaps be smaller; he has remained too long in the egg, and therefore his figure is not properly formed;” and then she stroked his neck and smoothed the feathers, saying, “It is a drake, and therefore not of so much consequence. I think he will grow up strong, and able to take care of himself.”


 

adopted family

The Adopted Family

My first storybook was The Adoptive Family. Mom made sure I knew the word "adopted" meant "chosen." My memory does not include a period in which I did not know I was a special child, a child they had prayed for, a child received as a gift from somebody else who couldn't keep me. 

I wondered about her, from the first time my family read that book together. Who was my First Mother? Where was she now? Did I look like her? Where did I come from?

My brother (two years my junior) was Mom and Dad's joyful "Oops" who arrived 18 months after I did. They hadn't planned to get pregnant again--their first son died only hours after he was born of a congenital heart defect. But born David was, and he was most definitely their child, through and through.

P5080005

My family was earthy. Emotive in the extreme. Lived in and for the moment. Prone to explosive outbursts. Pragmatic. Reality-bound. Commonsense. Tough-headed and tough-hearted.

I loved them, of course. We were family. But I was an alien. They bounded out of bed at the crack of dawn; I was a natural night owl. David was always outside, riding bicycles, running, jumping, climbing trees; I coccooned in my room drawing and reading. 


You don’t understand me,” said the duckling.

“We don’t understand you? Who can understand you, I wonder? Do you consider yourself more clever than the cat, or the old woman? I will say nothing of myself. Don’t imagine such nonsense, child, and thank your good fortune that you have been received here. Are you not in a warm room, and in society from which you may learn something?


Filling out medical forms made me crazy.

"Do you have a family history of X?"

I don't fucking know.

Mom and Dad always understood my frustration and curiosity about my biological roots, and they both let me know it was natural. To a large extent, they shared the frustration. Both made unsuccessful inquiries on my behalf when I was in my teens with the adoption agency, trying to find out more information about where I came from. Turns out they didn't know the right questions.

My first serious attempt to find out something about my family of origin came in 1989. I'd begun to research how to go about finding biological parents and was pleasantly surprised to find that I was entitled to a "Social History." The agency required that the request come from Mom, not me; she was happy to oblige.

And so, age 21, I received the following.

P5080043

Grammatically incompetent and wildly disorganized, my Social History read like a very bad soap opera script.

  • "Denise's birthmother...was described as an attractive, intelligent girl who was rather quiet and very personality in her manner, speech, and dress."  (??? very personality in her manner??? Is that even English?)
  • "Her father had two younger sisters...His youngest sister had some emotional problems. She had a hysterectomy after her second baby and has since needed psychiatric care."
  • "Denise's (birth grandmother) was described as very high strung, talkative, and nervous. At age six she was hit by a grocery truck...As a result of the accident she was very nervous." (For years, my first husband and I joked about my genetic predisposition to be hit by grocery trucks.)
  • "Denise's birthmother was the oldest of five children. A sister, 13, had a bad case of pneumonia and was born with some allergy. (sic)A brother, 11, had emotional problems. The entire family was seeing a psychologist for counseling. A sister, 9, had some difficulty breathing when she was born but was healthy in 1967. A brother, 5, was in good health."
  • "Denise's birthfather...had a severe case of acne and enlarged tonsils which were not infected all the time but they were always swollen."

Surely you can see why I couldn't WAIT to find these people, yes?


The duckling had never seen any like them before. They were swans, and they curved their graceful necks, while their soft plumage shown with dazzling whiteness. They uttered a singular cry, as they spread their glorious wings and flew away from those cold regions to warmer countries across the sea. As they mounted higher and higher in the air, the ugly little duckling felt quite a strange sensation as he watched them.


P5080006

 

Dad--er, ahem, Santa--Mom, and me, the year I got the Barbie Townhouse.


By 1989, when Mom obtained my Social History for me, it was down to just the two of us. Dad had died in 1985 of a massive, sudden heart attack in the middle of my Senior year in High School. Mom had already moved to Southern California; David and I dodged social services long enough for me to turn 18 in January, and we finished out that school year.

In 1987, David died in a car accident. He was just a few months shy of 18.

Mom is one of the strongest human beings I have ever known. To lose not one son, but both, and to go on, and to retain the ability to laugh...I cannot imagine the wells of emotional reserve that flow within her. I only know that I cannot fathom what she has been through as a mother, and I am privileged to be her daughter.

 

P5080007
David, Mom and Me, just before she left Illinois in 1985.

 


“I will fly to those royal birds,” he exclaimed, “and they will kill me, because I am so ugly, and dare to approach them; but it does not matter: better be killed by them than pecked by the ducks, beaten by the hens, pushed about by the maiden who feeds the poultry, or starved with hunger in the winter.”


I had to get my birth records opened. At 27--I think I was probably dieting too much, because I developed a slight heart-skipping-beat thing--I suddenly had a good medical reason to go searching again.

I didn't tell the docs about the dieting; screw that. I needed a good medical reason to pursue "identifying information," and a wonky heartbeat would work just fine.

Turned out sometime in the intervening 5 years, Ilinois adoption law had changed, allowing for a "confidential intermediary" search. Gold. The Mother Lode (no pun intended.) I scraped together $350 (not an easy thing to do when two young spouses are in grad school together, living off $8K teaching stipends--thanks for that, Michael) to send to a church I'd left long ago.

I went to the college psychologist to be certified as sane-enough-to-search.

And lo and behold, the floodgates opened.

The agency reached my bio-grandparents within a day (they'd never moved), and they in turn contacted Mothership.

Who absolutely flipped her lid.

She'd been waiting and hoping for a call or some kind of contact from me since I turned 18, she told me later. When that call didn't come, she figured I wanted nothing to do with her.

Nothing could have been further from the truth.


To be born in a duck’s nest, in a farmyard, is of no consequence to a bird, if it is hatched from a swan’s egg. He now felt glad at having suffered sorrow and trouble, because it enabled him to enjoy so much better all the pleasure and happiness around him; for the great swans swam round the new-comer, and stroked his neck with their beaks, as a welcome. 


 

P5080040

The first photo I ever saw of Ellen--yet another reason to make my heart skip a beat. Sweet Jesus, we looked like twins.

I wrote a long letter to my birthmother, introducing myself, telling her I in no way wanted to intrude, but I had always wondered about her, about so many of the quirks and idiosyncracies that set me apart from my family. I caught her up on my life--as much as you can sum up 27 years in just a few pages. I sent the letter to the adoption agency (they were still acting as an intermediary) and included my real address and phone number.

Three days later, I received a letter back.

P5080041

Yes, that is her handwriting. Not a font.

P5080042

The entire letter, laid out on my table


Then he rustled his feathers, curved his slender neck, and cried joyfully, from the depths of his heart, “I never dreamed of such happiness as this, while I was an ugly duckling.”


The reunion itself was really quite amazing.

For one thing, when Ellen and I found each other, we were living in "twin towns" in Iowa and Missouri (just barely across the state lines from each other). Kirksville, MO and Ottuma, Iowa (yes, Radar O'Reilly's hometown)  share a common TV station (KTVO) and are just 60 miles apart. We later realized we should have milked the reunion story for some airtime. :-)

Odder still, had I been able to afford my first choice of college--Grinnell--Ellen and I would have been living in that very town at the same time. We could hypothetically have encountered each other in the grocery store.

Our first meeting (a couple of days after we first talked on the phone) was, as I've alluded to elsewhere, very much like the moment E.T. was reunited with his family on the Mothership after he'd been taken in and cared for by Elliott and his friends. At last! My people! This is where I come from! This is where I was made! 


P5080008

1996

When The Big Maternal Family Reunion happened, I was over the moon. My memories are hazy mostly because they are so crowded together with the overwhelming nature of finally finding, not just a few people with whom I shared a genetic heritage, but HUNDREDS of them.

I told Mothership, "I always wanted to know who I looked like growing up. [pause, looking around]  Damn. It's EVERYBODY."

I got to meet my grandparents and my great-grandmother. They were warm, welcoming, full of hugs and kisses and tears.

I sat up with Mothership, and with her brothers and sisters (none of whom resembled the psychotic clan described in my Social History, it must be said) and their spouses until the wee hours of the morning. We made the same kinds of jokes. We shared the same absurd and sarcastic sense of humor. We revelled in each other's stories. We toasted Family.

When Mothership and I finally crashed to get some sleep in the reunion hotel room we were sharing, we discovered we both sleep in the same position: On the left side, in fetal position, with one pillow over the head and one under.

Weird.


Mothership and I have been friends and family for almost 15 years now. We've shared a home for several months. We've shared ups and downs and side-to-sides. We're friends who just happen to share DNA, and yet we're also more than that.

She also is friends with Mom--the woman who wanted me, and raised me, and is still Mom. Last year, we went on a joint family vacation of sorts, when Grandma turned 90 and Ellen (and some of my aunts and uncles on that side of the family) all took a grand cruise to Mexico. Me, Mom, Mothership, Uncles and Aunts from my family, and Birth-Uncles and Birth-Aunts, all sitting together at a group of swaying tables in the Pacific, made family by the very presence of...me. Silly little me. The baby that two women wanted, but only one woman could raise.

How odd.

How wonderful.

How sad that so many adoption reunion stories don't have such a happy ending.


PA180124

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
It shouldn't be shrunk...if anything, it should be expanded. Such odd lives we've led, picaresque in a way.
This was just glorious and beautiful, Denise. I loved every word of it. I can't get over Mothership's *handwriting*... wow! A million times rated for this wonderful story! Hugs.
There was absolutely no way to make this short.
All Ugly Duckling excerpts, of course, from Hans Christian Anderson.
I'm still waiting for you to get off the sonnet kick, Michael, and into the jaw-dropping memoir you have in you. Shoot. Start with being kidnapped at age 5 and go from there...
That was really lovely. I'm not going to say anything else lest I spoil the mood.

but i can't resist adding, that's a helluva clock in the santa pic
Cartouche--trust me, it's even creepier when you lay out all of those pages in full. That handwriting COULD be turned into a font by somebody who's skilled at such things.

Sandra--all I can say is I was not, thankfully, drinking anything when I read your clock comment. :-) Yes, it was a HELL of a clock.
Ahhh, as somewhat new here I am just getting to know about the people whose blogs I adore and follow. Yours is one of them, as is your Mothership's. I love getting the background from you like this, and getting to know your other mother from her words.

I'm very touched by your stories and the complexities you make sound so simple.

A real pleasure to get to know you both...you three!
What a tour de force! No shortening...more! As much as you want to.
Thanks for sharing an incredible story. Rated and rated and rated.
Loved this story, Denise. Glad you had a happy ending within all of this. Lots of tragedy with your first family and in your youth, perhaps more joy with the second half. I am glad to learn it. Also, isn't it odd how many habits are genetically linked?
Read Mothership's account the other day, VR, and was fair blown away. This side of the story is even more poignant, if that's possible, and touching. I'm glad you two found each other. A terrific story.

Rated
I'm so glad you had the experience you did, and that finding your people gave you insight into yourself and peace. I wish my own daughter's birth family were as positive . . . I can really see this as a magazine piece. It belongs in print.
I am so happy for you all. Mother's day has so many meanings, and you have demonstrated several of them. Lovely essay. Amazing story.
VR, I have looked so forward to this story, and am following Mothership's chapters as well. I hope the two of you turn it into a book. I wish I had your skill with words so that I could convey the sense of joy I felt reading this today. Your writing - and your life - is a gift.
Perfect in so many ways.
One heck of a great story.....an epic journey...and the handwriting!!!
Beautiful. Thank you both for being so giving of yourselves and your stories.
Well. Okay. Way to give Me a wonky heart, Denise. And btw, Sandra has a good eye. I was stuck on the Barbie Townhouse after I stopped crying, but whatever. I will be reading this many, many times. And for cryin out loud, give us more!
That is the happiest ending ever, and my favorite mother's day story so far.
A beautiful story - beautifully and artistically presented.

Blessings.
Wow. I know in my heart that my oldest daughter dreams of a reunion like this. Sadly, that is an impossibility. We know who her birth mom was but it seems that she has dropped off the face of the earth. (ironically, she began looking at 18 also and she is now 27...maybe this will be the year) Lucky you...your extended family had roots in one place.
Good for you. Good for Mothership. I'm so glad your adoptive mom has you too and that you understand her love.
I love the happy ending, especially since I know it's yours.
Gulp. I'm not seeing well at the moment..eyes full of tears tend to blur one's vision. How triumphantly beautiful...your words...and YOU...
And it is your Mom and I that are the lucky ones... each to have known the joy of having you as our daughter...
I love you more than my own words can express...
I forgot to mention that I sleep the same way with the pillows (and they *must* be mushy, feather ones), except I do it on my stomach. Does this mean we could be related? ;)
What a beautiful story, complete with a happy ending--it makes me want to give a certain Belgian-Irish-English American a big hug.
what a beautiful story....i hopoe some day to find out about my birth father...not many clues at this point, but yoru story reignited the spark of curiosity....just lovely, and you are insanely talented...
Denise, what a beautifully written post and what a story to live! I find it fascinating that you shared so many things with mothership, the way you sleep, the sense of humour... so many things are cultural and so many other are genetic and then personal... you are unique, a true pearl really.
A very happy Mother´s day to your Mom, and to your Mom!
Kisses
I keep wanting to cry as I read this, but I hold back. This is a great story. (I am so sorry about your brother, but I am glad your mom --by this I mean adopted mom--has you.) I couldn't help but notice already that your avatar looks just like your mom (by this I mean 'mothership').
What Rob said. Wow, you've lived. Amazing story that I will need to reread again and again to let my brain absorb it all.

LOVE
Awwwwwwwwww. Thanks, everybody. I'm pretty darned lucky.
i was crying through much of this. very well written, of course. i am off to read mothership's post. you DO look like twins. how nice it must be for everyone, that your mom and mothership became friends.
WOW, VR A wonderful story, the very things dreams are made of.

I'm printing this for my 20 year old adopted daughter to read.

Thank you for such a brilliantly written tale of your life. And what a gorgeous swan you've turned into.
i came back to look again. i remember first seeing the picture of my older sister where she looked just like me. but what i came back to say is, i bet where it says "very personality" it is supposed to say "very personable," which fits with the rest of the description.
What a great story. What a great writer. You do rock the house, you do!
What an amazing story this is. I agree with Annette that it should be a book.

You've had a lot of tragedy in your life, but you are blessed to have two wonderful mothers.
This is absolutely sublime. What a marvelous story -- extremely poignant. And I'm so glad it ends happily. Thank you for sharing this.
OS - this story has been rated on DIGG. Just press the second to last icon on Share rate it - (Digg is the icon between the f and the checkerboard).
This needs to be a movie. Wow!
What a great story. Wow. A touching Mother's Day story.

This is just wonderful.
MJ
Ya just can't beat a happy ending. Loved that it was interspersed with bits from "The Ugly Duckling."
Thanks for this beautifully written beautiful story! I cried while reading it, the emotion kept making knots in my throat.
You and Mothership should put it all in a book, with alternate chapters.
I am so glad you could not only find each other, but accept each other and love each other too. It does not always work like that and yours is a story of hope and love.

I am sad for your Mom who lost 2 sons in such tragic cricumstances. When a child loses his or her parents, "orphan" is the word that describes his or her status. There is no word to describe a parent who has lost a child or children. Not in any Indo-European languages, and not in any Semitic languages. (I researched that for a friend who lost her 8 year son.)

If I could rate it multiple times, I would. I just love yours and Mothership's posts.

And... I love Mothership's handwriting!
Very beautiful Denise, Rated and again Rated!
Back for a 2nd reading---and am speechless (doesn't happen a lot) and in awe of this story. This story brings hope alive.
"..we both sleep in the same position: On the left side, in fetal position, with one pillow over the head and one under." I forgot to mention, ME TOO! Is Mothership sure there aren't any Jewish relatives?
I'm struck by so much of what you've written, especially the "social history" - which I found both hilarious and creepy - and your birth mother's beautiful handwriting and somewhat matter-of-fact letter. I'm sure you consider yourself lucky that your story is more the exception rather than the norm.
Beautifully told. Just the right length. Thank you for sharing this touching story.
Lovely and tragic...I offer no comedy or quips.
Amazing, VR, just amazing. In a world full of bad news, it is inspiring to hear something so very, very unequivocally good, in the most meaningful possible ways. Congratulations to both of you!
A wonderful story, and one that you are fortunate to have been able to play the pivotal role in. As you can imagine, it is a tale I am very interested in, and makes me happy that ours is an open adoption. Even when the "mothership" chose not to meet in person, it still provided a connection that is psychologically healthy. Both your Mom and birth mom sound like a very good, supportive women worthy of love.
nothing really to say that hasn't been said. but kudos to you & mothership!
Such a lovely, artful way to frame your amazing story. (I’d deny the humanity of anyone who didn’t get choked up reading this – especially at the point of seeing your birth mother’s amazing letter to you).

As everyone knows, you have such undeniably unique talents when it comes to writing. So I’ll join the call of others for you to make more of this (or anything else you do here).
VR -- I we should be paying you to read this story. Well someone should be. As the father of adopted daughters, whose biological parents both had criminal records, this is such a heartwarming story, wonderfully told. Sorry, I missed this earlier.
Wow, what an inspiring story. I can only hope that when I do decide to go looking that I'll be half as lucky...
oh man, I'm sitting here shaking Verbal, how unpredictably amazing of and for all of you
Thanks for sharing your story! Now I can't wait to read Mothership's side of the tale.

Second - was I the only one laughing about the social history? Aren't you glad your family ended up being normal?!

So glad you've found each other!
Unreal. Endings don't get much better, and life stories don't often get told as well. Sorry for your loss of your brother, and your Dad. Happy for your new, extended family. Love the idea of a "social history".
God, your writing is so exquisite. You are a master of the craft.
The story is also exquisite - and I thank all of your family for allowing your gift to shine through to the rest of us.
VR, my eyes are blurring over just thinking about this. I have a question: did you connect with your birth father as well?
Your writing is wonderful, as always.

And you are so very lucky. Yes, I am envious.
What a powerful story. You made me cry on this lovely Sunday morning. I'm so glad you found each other!
thank you for sharing your story (and for mixing with it Ugly Duckling). as i commented to Mothership, it must have taken quite a measure of pain/processing/understanding/forgiving/etc. to be able to write this so candidly, and i have much respect for the work you've both put into getting this far with it. so happy that you've reconnected :)