The plight of the single, middle-aged newcomer in Smalltown
Before I write anything else, I'd just like to note that I'm going to do my best to refrain from leaving any clues as to my precise whereabouts. This is partly because I honestly believe that my situation is one in which any single person could find him or herself if he/she were to move to a small town, and partly because I'm pretty sure that if I were to give the name of my small town, I might get a chorus of, "Oh, but Small Town is a fine place! How can you say that?" Assuming anyone reads this, that is.
A little background information is in order here. I'm a college professor, and before moving to Small Town a couple of years ago, I taught at Giant State Research University (GSRU) in the western United States. GSRU was a great place to work, and I loved my job, my students and my colleagues, several of whom were my good friends. I also loved Mid-Sized City, where GSRU was located. It was a college town much like others in this country, but with enough independent industry (that is, independent from GSRU) to keep life interesting and to avoid that insular feeling that college towns often develop. It had great independent and chain bookstores -- new and used, a thriving arts scene, several independent movie theatres that showed foreign and art films (and not just the ones nominated for Oscars), fantastic dining, and a diverse population. By "diverse", I mean that the population was not only ethnically diverse, but politically, economically, socially and age-wise. It was -- and still is -- a magnificent place to live.
So why did I leave this earthly paradise? Greed.
GSRU is a wonderful place to be a teacher or a student, but a lousy place to make a living. Salaries were in the bottom quartile of salaries for university faculty around the country, and cost-of-living raises few and far between. What merit pay was available could be acquired only after a lengthy and exhausting "verification" process that was hardly worth the meager raise. I'm in my forties, and the fear of hitting my fifties with little in savings or my 403(b) to show for it was keeping me awake nights. For a while, I contemplated leaving GSRU and looking for a job in the private sector, but I love teaching, and after fifteen years of it, I can honestly say that I'm only now getting any good at it. I still feel that I have something to offer young people, and I know that they still have much to teach me.
So when the job description for my present position was posted to the Chronicle of Higher Education and certain listservs, and several friends sent me links to the description with notes: "You HAVE to look into this!", I decided that the time had come for a major move. The description was certainly attractive: a nine-month contract at Tiny Comprehensive University, with collective bargaining for faculty, a salary around $30,000.00 more than I made at GSRU, and based in a little town with cheap, plentiful housing. I applied, and got the job. Four months later, I had bought a house in Small Town, moved myself and my pets all the way across the country, and tried to settle down and settle in.
Now if only my new neighbors would talk to me. If only there were some place I could meet people my age other than in church or bars. If only there were something to do in this city other than go to the tiny mall, go to the single multiplex movie theatre, go to the single, Large Chain bookstore (I'll give you a hint: there's a "B" and an "N" in its name) in the entire city, go walking, go drinking, or go quietly nuts.
Much of Small Town's civic life is inextricably entwined with the church scene. Churches around here come in two flavors: a rigid, pre-Vatican II Catholicism and a dull, gray mainline Protestantism of the sort gently lampooned by Garrison Keillor. Keillor makes it all sound so wonderfully quaint and charming, but let me tell you, absent his lovely sepia wash, that sort of churching will kill your spirit in very short order. Both the Catholics and Protestants offer an unending cycle of jumble sales, bingo games, revivals, Bible studies, and potlucks.
I've lived in Small Town for three years, and I've visited three different churches. The first two were Catholic (I was raised in that church). The second was Missouri Synod Lutheran, and I visited for a few weeks at the behest of a coworker at Tiny Comprehensive. The only difference between the churches is that the Missouri Synod Lutherans don't have the Infant of Prague or the Mother of Sorrows staring at you in church during services, and the Lutherans are also far better singers. Additionally, the Catholics have prettier churches and better food at their potlucks. The church I attended in Mid-Sized City was nondenominational and quite progressive in its theology. Here in Small Town, "progressive" means "heretical."
I'm not married, and I left no significant other behind in Mid-Sized City. I have no children other than my pets. I'm a short, decidedly chubby, middle-aged college professor with a double chin and a pronounced waddle. I don't have a scintillating personality or a charming smile that would distract anyone from the hard truths I just listed. And yet, I've met a substantial number of women I've met who think I'm just waiting for them to turn their backs so I can pounce on their men, drag them back to my house and do depraved, undoubtedly perverted and possibly illegal things to their bodies. This makes me grin. Some of the men think I'm waiting for an opportunity, too. This makes me roll my eyes. Admittedly, it's a novelty for me to be seen as some sort of wanton hussy, but the charm of it has grown pale. I'm tired of women grabbing their husbands' arms when I walk by, and I'm very tired of having to stop myself from snarking, "Oh, really ... who the hell wants your husband anyways, aside from you?"
The single, local multiplex has 20 screens. At any given time, ten of them will be showing two Hollywood blockbusters (five screens for each film), and the other ten will feature an assortment of movies that have been out for a few weeks. None will show an independent or foreign film. "Slumdog Millionaire" didn't show up until it was nominated for an Oscar, and it was in the theatres for two weeks. This summer, I expect to have to choose between Harry Potter, Transformers 2, Star Trek and X-Men: Wolverine for my viewing pleasure ... or get something from Netflix. Small Town has one Hollywood Video and some Redbox kiosks in the supermarkets, none of which carry independent or art films.
I like my job at Tiny Comprehensive, and I like my students (I'll write about them in another post). But Tiny Comprehensive has negligible music, drama and arts programs, so the likelihood of Small Town developing a live music or arts scene is pretty dim. The nearest major city is two hours away, and it has many excellent universities, small and large, so college students in this state looking for good arts programs don't enroll in Tiny Comprehensive. Young people who come of age in Small Town leave as soon as they can, either to attend college elsewhere or to find work and a livelier scene. The ones who stay and do not enroll in Tiny Comprehensive either expect to join their parents in some family business or on the family farm, or take retail and service jobs in Small Town and quickly settle into an unbudging, unblinking quiescence.
Even if there were an arts scene, or better theatres, or better bookstores, I'd still have no-one with whom to share them. I'm too old to hang out with college kids, even if my faculty status didn't make that problematic. Most of the faculty at Tiny Comprehensive is either approaching retirement age and just ticking off the days until they move to Florida or Arizona, or young marrieds with children whose off-campus lives revolve around said children, and there's not much room for an unmarried woman with no children in their scene. The few single men and women I've met here, at work and off-campus, are native Small Town'ers who have longstanding relationships with other natives, and no need or desire to keep company with a newcomer.
In this economy, I'm grateful to have a job that pays as much as mine does. Truly. I'm well aware that securing a well-paid tenure-track position like mine is nothing short of a miracle, and that there are better, more experienced teachers than I who are working in confidence-destroying adjunct jobs for little pay and less respect. Small Town is such a cheap place to live, and my salary so high, that I'm saving a huge amount of money without even trying very hard.
But good grief, I'm lonely here. Well-paid and prospering, but lonely. I may have to give up my dreams of a materially comfortable retirement, move back to Mid-Sized City or someplace like it, and work for the rest of my life -- a life filled with friends and intellectual stimulation, one hopes. I could deal, I think.


Salon.com
Comments
Funny, I was lonely while living with 4 other people and a dog, but not so much while living alone.
After all, now you have OS on Saturday nights!
I suggest inviting people over or starting a book club or something else where you have people over once a month.... could get interesting.
I think many, many can relate to your story. The fact you have to "shield" your identity is stifling itself. Think of it as a community service and you are a missionary of sorts. Help as many kids as you can find a way out of there. In that way you have a mission there.
All evidence to the contrary in the above post. Welcome -- looking forward to hearing more!
I know the faculty frequently climbed walls. Some at least.
The bars were, by necessity, "mixed." Town and gown drank side-by-side at the place I frequented most--not the frat bar, not the hardcore townie bar, but the bar where the proprietor put on a twice-yearly "Elvis" impersonation show. Himself. The way we all went with it, swooning when he draped us with a sweaty scarf, remains one of my fondest memories.
I'd say ditch the churches and find a fun bar, but then, I know it's really not that easy.
But I could relate. Thumb.
Looking forward to more, and a warm welcome to one with such obvious talent.
The second thing I thought of is a piece I heard on NPR a couple weeks back. It was a community in Ohio with a thriving arts community, against all odds - oh, let me go find it.
But it was about an area, I think cited below, that's small, middle in size, and has had a thriving arts and music and theater community for Years. And the people, many conservative, most middle class, attend, support, and are proud of same.
You could be the or an impetus - even behind the scenes, sometimes that's more rewarding - for same in your community. And who better to put forward this but your college? I guarantee there are students there that would love some artistic stimulus. See where you can go with this idea.
I can't imagine moving back to smalltown, but the idea is tempting. The $$ stretch So much farther there. It's probably where I'll end up.
Thanks for writing, by the way! It's well-writ, thoughtful, and not overly self-pitying.
Know also that even in the big Cities - NY, SF, LA - most of "us" are toodling and noodling along on our computers, out there searching for a community.
http://www.dispatchpolitics.com/live/content/life/stories/2009/03/08/1_ARTS_CHECK.ART_ART_03-08-09_E1_PHD3FVC.html?sid=101
Verbal Remedy, ocularnervosa - I know well there are yet smaller towns with even fewer amenities. I can't imagine living in one of them. I doubt I'd have the strength to write, let alone the coherency.
I wish there were a truly "mixed" bar here, Verbal Remedy. I have found one place that's sort of mixed: the townies come in on the weeknights, and the gowns, students and faculty, come in on the weekends. I went by myself one Tuesday night, and had a pretty good time.
I've wondered if it'd be any better if I were married with children, and I'm pretty sure it would be. I was hired at Tiny Comprehensive at the same time as another professor in my department, and she came with hubby and children in tow. She loves it here, and she's already knitted herself into the community ... by joining the PTA, den mothering the Cub Scouts, and doing other parent-like things. I don't have that option.
ConnieMack, I think I'll be traveling as much as possible for the next couple of years or so on my off days -- at least, as much as I can without frittering away my savings. With luck, the economy will improve in a year or two, and then I'll start looking for a job again.
Again, thanks to all who responded! I feel better already!
Maybe what you need is to truly go to a "Small Town", one without a metroplex or B&N. The last city where I lived in the midwest was a town of 12,000 in Iowa with self-contained economic base and a Methodist affiliated liberal arts college of 1400. Now, that's a small town and it still isn't close to the smallest that I've lived in.
Sorry, but it ain't the size of the town. Maybe it's....
Rated
What I've learned after 15 years of reinventing myself is that sometimes great things come from loss, and you never know what you're saving yourself from with the move you've made. I'd say hang in there for another 2-3 years, and I would almost bet you'll be happy with the place you're in. Of course, I have a pretty "it's meant to be attitude" about most things, which impacts my response to dealing with crap and its aftermath.
denese
What worked for me was really simple and I could have kicked myself for not doing it sooner. Volunteering. Holy crap, all of the sudden I went from counting change on Saturday morning while watching TV to having actual stuff to do with real adults.
There are amazing people everywhere - they just don't advertise.
navelgazer, I LOVE libraries. And the first place I looked for friends outside of the aforementioned churches and bars was our local public library, which does indeed have some book groups: the knitters' book group, the folks who love to cook book group, the scrapbook book group ... you get the picture. I honestly think it's not just the size of the city, but the location in the USA, the history of the city, and the dominant culture of the place. Small Town is the place in this area of the state where people from smaller towns come to enjoy the big metropolis and to shop, and the metropolis obliges by making chain stores like Lane Bryant, Olive Garden and Famous Footwear available.
Leonde, I hear you. I do make the occasional trip to the big city two hours away (usually about once a month) to see an art film and eat in a restaurant that isn't advertised on national TV. But you're right: the sticks aren't for everyone.
Denese, I envy you. You moved for love of family -- probably the best reason to move there is. I moved away from family for money, and I miss them terribly. It's probably that, combined with the lack of culture in Small Town, that will eventually drive me back to Mid-Sized City.
BkLvr, I've been to Mankato. I like Mankato. Small Town should aspire to Mankato. And I think I just drew a bead on myself ...
RT
http://www.anonymity.es.tc
And if all else fails, you sound as if you can find another job in another place. Anyway, welcome here!
Mid-size is so nice...but give a wee bit of time. You'll find your zone, maybe.
After my initial shock wore off, and I shook the snow (!) off my boots, I discovered a little place of enormous love. I also follow Freaky Troll here on OS almost religiously, and what that beautiful Troll has taught me, he/she being a Doctor of Divinity, is that it's all about me me me. What can I bring to this town? What do I have to offer? Well, that took me right down to the Democratic Headquarters, where I made lots of friends. The lunch program for the homeless at a local church needed volunteers, and the library has a book club.
I've met some of the zaniest, hilarious, individuals in Loveland! On Friday nights, a friend of mine screens foreign films in his living room. That's better than some old cineplex any day.
Anyway, hang in there! It can get better....
AND I get the move to a small town too...since I just moved with my husband to the mid west and hate it here. I sympathize with you a great deal Viscountess. At least I have the hubby.
It has been horribly difficult trying to make friends here. Our city sounds maybe a little larger than yours...but there is similarly, nothing going on compared to where we lived in Colorado. To their credit, they JUST opened an "art house" theater here, and it shows films other than the main stream.
The only thing I would advise for you is to travel, travel, travel! During your school breaks....get out and about if you can. Do it on the cheap if you are trying to save...but do it! I'd think that the only deterrent would be your pets...but that may be dealt with if you can find a sitter or kennel or something.
Hang in there...and keep writing here!
I miss my last home and all my friends, but I don't miss being a broke, unemployed graduate student. I tell myself that "Penurious Professor" is a more glamorous title. Moving here has comfirmed an idea that I always suspected was true: you make your own fun if you want to have any. I'd be willing to bet that some of those people who seem so inaccessible when you encounter them on the street are secretly longing for a smart new friend with a fresh perspective. Your challenge will be to figure out how to coax them out into the open. Good luck, Viscountess! I will follow your story with great interest. In the meantime, can any of your pets don a leash?
I'm lucky in that I live within driving distance of a nice, big, culturally diverse city with lots of stuff to do. But it's too far away to visit regularly so... out here amidst the sugar cane and the occasional cattle ranch, I feel the slow stagnation of my mental processes.
I concur with the suggestion to set aside some of your savings for travel. I have been traveling alone for over 30 years and can attest to its joys (and be honest about its drawbacks). There are lots of ways to travel on the cheap and doing the research for a trip is an absorbing "hobby" in and of itself. I find that going out of town for a weekend can be very refreshing. One reason I love to travel is that I find that it's okay to do things alone when one is away from home. I prefer to go to movies by myself, always have. But I hate to go to the theatre alone -- unless I'm out of town. Same with nice restaurants; never go to them alone when at home but love to include a fine dining experience when I'm traveling.
If travel isn't your cuppa and starting a salon isn't something you feel you can do, perhaps you can set yourself a goal for a project that might mitigate the loneliness. Perhaps you could read the entire set of the Great Books of the Western World. Or you could read all of a certain author's ouevre. Perhaps you could watch all of one director's films in chronologic order. Or watch all of the best picture Oscar winners starting with "Wings." Or maybe you could take up photography. Getting out and taking pictures is great fun, even or especially as a solo activity. If you go to Flickr and search for the name of your town under tags or titles, you might be surprised by what you find, you might even find that there is a group of photographers who get together in or near where you live.
Finally, Lady Dalrymple, if women are pulling their husband's closer when you are around, then we are left with one conclusion: that your self-description left out the good bits.
I'm in a city of 6,500, virtually no chain stores allowed, and higher education is the high school. We only have one movie theater, but a thriving art community. There are also many, many single women here, many are widows, but others are not.
I suggest finding out where people go to exercise, you would be surprised how quickly you meet people while doing your body good!
At any rate there are many excellent suggestions from others here. I hope soon you will be posting on the interesting people you have met!
Regarding the way you're treated by the couples ... Once in a while, a perverse sort of defiance gets the better of me, and I have a little fun with it: I flirt a little with a few of those married men, not out of any interest in them, but to confirm their wives' obvious suspicion that I really am a dangerous floozy, and that they should vigiliantly protect their husbands (or themselves?) around a vampy middle-aged gal like me. I figure I might as well have a little fun with it if I'm going to be looked upon as a man-stealing tart just because I'm not married.
I can relate in as much as, in my home country (France), once I became a civil servant teacher (public education pays better), I was indeed sent miles away (4 hours drive) from my town into a small city of about 45,000 people, with lights out by 8:00pm, and my family stayed behind: my husband and my then 4 year-old son, since my husband's job paid much more than mine. You can't argue with the State (the Ministry of National Education)'s decision to send you where it needs you. If you resign, you lose everything: title, fact that you actually passed the bloody certification exam with flying colors, and cannot even pretend to unemployment benefits.
The irony was that my husband's job then decided to move him to the States, where we have now been for 15 years, in DC, the capital city of the first power in the world. Of course, the Ministry could not tell me not to follow my husband and gave me 3 years of unpaid sabbatical, at the end of which I was considered as "having resigned" and lost everything (see above) because I did not return to my assigned position.
I thought life would be easy in DC, what with then 2 children... but hell, no! I was not allowed to work for the first 5 years. I have never been a Martha Stewart type (and never will), had always workeed full time thanks to great, affordable childcare and therefore was not used to life through kids only. To not fall into alienation, I started volunteering, created a book club that was answering my literary taste and style (not knitting, not cook book, but American literature for French expats), attended a writing workshop, joined a gym, and discovered that life was possible even in a town in which I knew noone.
I will not give you advice: all the other OS members did and said what I would have said too. Maybe you'll make some friends here, I have!
I agree with Walter Blevins' comment about Small Town life revolving around the kids. I have lived in a few Small Towns (I like them, strange as that may sound) and I have found Walter's observation to be true. If you can find a way to involve yourself in the lives of Small Town's children, you will probably discover ways to involve yourself in the lives of their parents as well. Volunteer work is good because money is almost always in short supply in Small Town, USA, especially in the current economic climate. Those to whom you volunteer your services will like you and speak highly of you to others. That would be a good start, don't you think? So, maybe you could volunteer to be a part-time teacher's aid. Or you could read to the elementary school kids during their library hour. Is there a sport you could volunteer to coach? Coaching would be a big time/energy commitment, but would probably be one of the quickest ways to insinuate yourself into the local community. Just showing up to watch the home football/basketball/baseball games is another way to get involved with Small Town's kids. That's where most of the parents, grandparents, cousins, aunts, uncles ... etc ... will be too.
But honestly, even if you manage to score some dinner invitations, and make friends who are willing to sit with you in the stands at the home games, cheering for touchdowns and home runs, is that what you really want? Three years is a long time to spend trying hard to fit in where you don't really want to be. I think you've given it a spectacular try, without much reward to show for your efforts. It sounds like you miss the shopping, arts, restaurants, and cultural climate that Big City had to offer, a lot. Might it be possible to look for another position, in a bigger city, that pays better than GSRU did?
You have pets? I know you can't say what kind but - perhaps you can also bond with some locals who have the same. Ferret and cavy families seem particularly good at bonding over the common issues they face. Reaching out via the internet - that would have been my first recommendation - and now you have.
Since you write so well, I am keen (that's Australian for I WANT THIS MADLY) to hear about your adventures teaching...when you feel like it.
Small towns in the Pacific Northwest (where we are now) are much more progressive, and the people are making interesting life decisions and are open to ideas. Small towns that I experienced out in Minnesota were full of Missouri Synod clone-people. They scared me: mostly because they were so boring and soul-less, NOT because the town didn't have resources.
It's Minnesota, not the size of the town.
There is no dim sum.
Well...I am not pressing....
But going from that to this, even with buttloads of cash....is hard. Even though I am coveting the cash mightily.
I say you hoard for a while...and then boogie, but you aren't looking for advice.
I am in the same spot..move from Los Angeles to upstate NY...what I wouldn't do for a girlfriend....a real girlfriend. Have the guy: that was the reason for the move.
Sigh....hard. Welcome though...you write well...looking forward to more..
If you haven't got any money don't you bother coming out
How you went broke is a story I don't want to here about,
If you want to call me honey bee, better bring a lot of do-re-mi
That sorta stuff you can't call on your baby without
If you haven't got any money don't you bother coming round
You ain't the only poodle in the pound
Say you love me and hope to die
But remember what it takes to qualify
And if you haven't got any money don't you bother coming by.
Moved to northeast town of 1500 after living in Chgo., Ct, LA, happy to have the peace that is here. But women are married, or not up to doing anything much. Same here, church and community volunteers. Job disappeared last year, thankfully I have plenty to do and a strong inner life. But it would be fun to have a girlfriend or two to do things with.
Suggestions..
1) do a Jolie.. adopt a foreign baby.. that will make you life interesting... probably fulfilling.
2) hope I can suggest this site... google "meetup" it's a site to find any activity/hobby group.. anywhere.. it's spectacular.. (as good for finding groups as Salon is for finding interesting writers)..
3) extra money? buy properties and become a landlord in your community.. power is extremely attractive to men.. and intimidating to women.
Just some thoughts and suggestions..
You do not seem as extreme as me. You are also in your 40's. You do not have a spouse or an SO. Therefore, you absolutely do have to think about things like tenure, salary, cost of living, the best health care benefits and retirement. Fortunately the college itself and its' students sound decent.
You also have a lot of other things going for you. The internet is one of the best. You can contact people all over the world for the intellectual stimulation you need. You can get a web cam so that you can actually see these people while you converse. You can join a dating service.
You now have the money and vacation/long weekend time to travel. Do it. Do it a lot. You will soon have many in person relationships.
Don't waste the majority of your time bloging alone. You have access to the world beyond smallville. Go get it.
I moved to my own Small Town over 20 years ago, and I'm afraid it took 10 years to find my niche. That's what it takes. For me, it was the music scene—I learned to play the French horn and joined the local summer band and concert orchestra. It saved my life.
I have been writing about my Small Town in Ohio using this exact term for about three years here—http://justayin-rob.blogspot.com/