AUGUST 20, 2009 6:30PM

No Compromise on the Public Option!

Rate: 0 Flag

I haven't posted in a while. I've been trying to keep the insulation in the walls, I guess. I'm pissed off about the health care con job, and my furniture agrees with me. I wrote a rant today and decided to post it. I'm no Plutonium Jones or whatever, but I'm trying.

Contact your senator and congressional rep today, and tell them how you feel, unless you want to tell them they are a Nazi born in Kenya, in which case never mind.

**********************************************

The issue of moving the goal posts in defining a reasonable compromise to get a health care bill passed—first it was giving up on single payer health care and now it is casting the public insurance option aside—has already been effectively refuted as an effective strategy by recent Republican obstructionist responses.

Let’s remember that single payer is demonstrably not some fringe utopian ideal, but a reasonable, valid method for reform of the American health care system. Every other civilized country has it already. Yet the Democrats in both houses took single payer off the table and compromised from the very beginning of the debate on a health care reform bill. Our legislators replaced single payer with a discussion of a public insurance alternative to compete with the megainsurance companies that are currently our only option, and thereby control skyrocketing costs.

For context, health insurance profits are up 1000 percent over the past five years- ONE_THOUSAND!-, partly from a 300-percent increase in average premiums, and the rest from denial of payment of normal fees for service. If you have frequently been refused payment for reasonable care by your insurance company, or reimbursed at far below your actual cost, you are far from alone. Now  the debate has passed to compromising on the public option and settling for health insurance co-ops.

Many pundits puts forth the option of co-ops as the definitive solution to the dilemma, but then later acknowledge—and this is significant—that the Republican senators and the Blue Dog Dems in fact and in the end oppose them too. For anyone fuzzy on what a co-op would be, here's an analogy: If the major insurance companies are Bank of America, the co-op would be your local credit union. As Bob Herbert said in his NY Times column "Forget about the nonprofit cooperatives. That’s like sending peewee footballers up against the Super Bowl champs."

The problem is that a co-op of sufficient size to negotiate effectively with the hospitals and drug companies for favorable rates would need to have so many enrollees that it would arguably and effectively be the public option; and any smaller would be laughed out of the room. We are in a sad state of affairs when Chuck Grassley, the lead negotiator for the Republicans on this issue from his seat on the Senate Finance Committee, acknowledges that even if he had the chance to write a bill to his specifications, he would have to vote against it because the Republican line is to oppose any reform measures at all. Their final answer is no to anything concrete, but they favor reform in the abstract. Whatever.

Wake up folkies: with a 60-seat majority in the Senate, an advantage of fifty seats in the House, and their president in the Oval Office, the Dems could pass any bill they wanted, including single payer. They could tell the obstructionist Republicans to go f**k themselves and push a bill through on their own. But they don't want to. Why? They're thinking about 2010. If they actually tried to pass such a bill, they know the insurance companies would punish them by donating to their opponents in local races. This is the problem with selling off the government to private industry and lobbyists: it's hard to get it back when you need it.

Call to Action: If you want the public option, you need to send an email or letter to your representatives in the Senate and the Congress TODAY. Tell them you are a voter in their district, and the public option is non-negotiable with you. Tell them that how they vote on this will affect how YOU vote in the next election. They are getting enormous pressure from lobbyists and even their own leadership—I’m looking at you Rahm Emmanuel, you Machiavellian prick—to compromise on the public option; make them feel the heat coming from the other direction to hold the line.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
i want what i want, and i want it now. but you won't work for real democracy, so you end up getting very little.

imagine how easy it would be, to get a good national health care plan if you had citizen initiative. unless more than half the voters are satisfied with what they've got. that's a possibility, and without any kind of referendum available to americans you have to take what the politicians think is best. best for them, of course.

'you get the government you deserve' covers it pretty well.
I'm not sure what 'you' Al aims his broadside at, but me I've been pretty active working in the mineshaft of real representative democracy lately.

I find it alarming that many folks don't know where their insurance actually comes from- that it comes through, but not from, their employer, and that if they are not happy with the insurance co and policies offered by their employer, they cannot go to another company unless they want to buy a policy on their own. It is at this time that folks get a big shock: they find out what insurance really costs. Insurance provided through an employer is subsidized by that employer. If you are paying 3K a year for insurance, chances are your employer is kicking in 9K. Actually though, you are really kicking in the other 9K, because of course they factor in their insurance costs when determining salaries.

I have a feeling we are all going to be learning a lot more about insurance in the next few months. It ain't over til it's over.
I touched on a similar subject today in a piece I recently posted. It seems the more things seem to change, the more they stay the same. Darth Vader wants to keep health care in the for profit system and let anyone that cannot afford it die while there is no one fighting for the uninsured. Amazing, how the Darth Vaders that condemn people to die without medical care make it sound like a national health plan for all would bring in death squads. Hitler once said if you tell a life enough times, it becomes the truth. Seems that's what the modern day conservative Darth Vaders are doing today--telling lies and turning them into truth sort of like turning iron into gold.