Winterpalace

a blog by Felisa Rogers

Felisa Rogers

Felisa Rogers
Location
Seattle,
Birthday
December 16
Bio
Generally, I'd rather be reading. But I am fond of arguing about dead presidents, driving vans around Mexico, and cooking. I try to create places and times that make you believe, just for a moment, that people aren't terrible and the world isn't a ghastly place.

MY RECENT POSTS

AUGUST 7, 2010 6:50PM

A Beach in the Balance--Mexican Riot Police Attack

Rate: 12 Flag

  la mosca

Restaurant "La Mosca" is gone, destroyed by the state police . The open air restaurant, with its sand floor and thatched pavilion, sat overlooking Tenacatita bay, on the coast of Jalisco, Mexico. The portly owner, Adrian, nicknamed "La Mosca" (the fly) for the mole on his forehead, had planted bougainvillea vines and flowers and painted the cinder block kitchen bright blue and green. It was from this modest facade that his wife Cuca served her famous chile rellenos, earning the restaurant a singular popularity and allowing the family to eke out a modest income, supplemented by Mosca's and Cuca's sons, who went out each dawn in a fiberglass skiff, or panga, to catch fish for the restaurant.

Naming a restaurant "The Fly" is a ballsy move, but, then again, La Mosca is a ballsy guy. He's not the only Tenacatita resident who had cojones. Since 1993, residents of the small fishing community and the nearby village, El Rebalsito, have defended the beach from violent attacks spearheaded by a the Rodenas Corporation, a development group with plans to build an elite gold resort on the property. In 1993, 1998, and 2006, Rodenas obtained the help of the state police to demolish the thatched buildings that dot the cove.

The problem? Most of the small restaurants, hotels, and stores on Tenacatita bay are operated by families that have lived on the land for generations. The beach attracts a regular flow of tourists from the United States, Canada, and Mexico City. Visitors camp in palapas (huts) or stay at one of the modest hotels, such as the Hotel Paraiso, which is operated by Maria and Felix Mendoza, who are of retirement age but who still work in the hotel every day--Maria in the kitchen, Felix at the desk. On Sundays, families from nearby towns flood to Tenactita--kids play in the surf and adults relax in the shade eating camarones al mojo de ajo and other local specialties. Profits from the restaurants, hotels, and camp spots fuel the economy of El Rebalsito, which has no other major industry.

Although most of the buildings on the beach have been burned or bulldozed more than once and residents have been repeatedly arrested, villagers have returned each time to rebuild. They've also fought the case in the courts. 

Jose Maria Andres Villalobos, head of the Rodenas group, contends that he purchased 42 hectares (about 103 acres) of beachfront property in 1991 from the widow of a former state governor. Although you can't legally own a beach in Mexico, Villalobos claims he obtained the beach concession rights in 1993. Locals say the land wasn't the widow's to sell in the first place and allege that Villalobos has a judge or two in his pocket.

Many of the beach's small business owners are members of the local ejido, or land cooperative. (The Mexican government created ejidos to implement the land reforms fought for in the revolution.) The Rebalcito ejido was established in 1940 and its holdings include the land that affords access to Tenacatita beach.

riot gear

reprinted form Milenio.com

On the morning of August 4, 2010, Jalisco State Police in full riot gear arrived to evict Tenacatita residents and business owners. Police stated  they  were acting on behalf of the Rodenas corporation; that a judge in the nearby  town of Autlan had issued a ruling in favor of the corporation. Locals resisted, demanding to see the paperwork from the ruling, which has still not materialized. Instead the police shot at the crowd with rubber bullets. They were aided by civilians in yellow shirts (possibly employees of the Rodenas Corporation) who broke car and house windows, smashed belongings, emptied the contents of the restaurant kitchens into the street, and demolished palapas. Locals allege that police also stole furniture and belongings.

The Mexican daily Milenio.com, which has been providing excellent coverage of the story, confirms that the police arrested 27 people, among them three suffering from bullet wounds: Guadalupe Israel, Fabián Vera and 75-year-old José Cruz Flores. Sevenenteen local residents were wounded in the altercation.

Police then barred access to the beach, and Milenio reports that the municipal secretary of La Huerta (a nearby town) and a Puerto Vallarta-based Jalisco Human Rights Commission observer were required to relinquish their cellphones and cameras to police before they were allowed to enter the area. On Friday the newspaper Mural quoted Villalobos on the subject: "Everything on the beach will be demolished. It's not infrastructure. It's only rubbish."

In retaliation, residents of Tenacatita and El Rebalsito set up a road block and protest on Highway 200, the main artery from Puerta Vallarta to Manzanillo. They were joined by supporters from neighboring communities. The ejido sent representatives to Guadalajara to seek help from the federal government: ejidatarios say that according to Mexican law this case should be settled at the federal level: that a circuit judge in Autlan has no business making proclamations in regard to a federally mandated institution such as an ejido.

Rumors that the judge was bribed are rampant, and some ejiditarios allege that Villalobos has powerful friends in the Mexican government. Other locals say the court order is completely fabricated, citing the following evidence: no one has seen it, and the police seemed edgy when asked for it, even threatening to kill one of the women who requested verification.

The actions of the ejido mirror their response to past incidents. In 1993, when developers tried to occupy the beach by setting up mobile homes inhabited by armed guards (occupation plays a vital role in Mexican land disputes),  local residents towed the trailers back to the highway with the guards inside. In 2006, when state police again attempted to seize the beach on behalf of the Rodenas corporation, the citizens of Rebalsito came out in mass. Women and children formed a human barrier across the road, standing their ground against riot police armed with machine guns.

The Mexican news service Noticistema reports that since taking control of the beach the Rodenas corporation has built a fence that cuts through Tencatita's mangrove swamp, which is protected under federal law. Because Rodenas did not get official permission to cut mangroves, the Jalisco delegation of PROFEPA (a federal environmental agency) are scheduled to appear at the beach on Monday to denounce the perpetrators. 

A local man (name withheld for his protection) who visited the beach on Saturday reports that access is still blocked and fish from the restaurant kitchens rots in the street. Palapas lie splintered, and homes and restaurants have been looted of furniture and other valuables. In Rebalcito, store owners report that they're already seeing the results of the town being cut off from its major source of revenue: people are asking to buy on credit.

Teenage detainees from the August 4 incident were released; several have black eyes and all had been beaten. One boy was covered with wounds from rubber bullets. Another detainee reports that prisoners were tortured with electric wires.

The nearby municipality of La Huerta has come out in support of Tenacatita residents, stating that many of the evictees have titles to their property and therefore the action by the state police is not supportable.

Ejiditarios obtained a temporary cease-and-desist order from the federal government but, as of the time that this was written, local residents reported that the state police were still occupying their homes and businesses. 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Wow!
How horrible is all of this?
:(
Rated with hugs
This pretty much sums it up, to date. Thanks for writing this! We need media attention to the situation!
thank you so much for writing this, it is so important that people know what is happening down there.
that beach means so much to us and i know that is nothing compared to what it means to the people who live there. i wish there was something we could do to prevent another stupid resort from ruining more lives and more beautiful beach.
Thanks all! I really appreciate your support. Becky: I agree. I wish more people in power in Mexico understood that many of us go south for places that are distinctly Mexican, and that we won't go to Mexico the day the entire coast is eaten up by giant corporate resorts.
Fascinating and sad story. Well done. Corporate greed makes me sick.
Great article. A lot that was up before was a little fuzzy. Two small corrections. Those long fisherman boats are "pangas" not "pongas" and the town is Rebalsito. They have a website that servs as a union for the few townspeople with an Internet connection and the people that are in the states. www.rebalsito.com >This would be a great article there also as many people from there that are in the states speak English.
Thanks! And Cyberpueblo, thanks for the corrections. Spelling has never been my strong point. I will check out the rebalsito site.
A horrifying experience to live through. And hardly even mentioned on the news. Thank you for such a thorough coverage. I hope justice is restored soon - is that too much to ask for? Rated.
This is so unbelievably messed up. Keep us posted on the developments.
More needs to be said about this. Tenacatita is a beautiful place.
Another typical Mexican coastal property deal done among wealthy Mexican influentials with the sole purpose of enriching themselves with absolutely no concern for the local citizens who rightfully claimed that land through the Ejiditaro system . No Mexican beach is safe from them. No doubt every Mexican beach entrance eventually will have a little caseta (booth) with a guard in it telling you that you can’t access the beach because it is private property. Nice touch for Villalobos to mention that an international group of investors is involved thus using gringos as the scapegoats. My heart goes out the Tenecatita residents and again have a hard time believing how inhumanly cruel the Mexican politicians and elite can be to fellow citizens who are on the bottom rung of the economic ladder. Doesn't the Policia Estatal (State Police) have some real criminals to go after like maybe the narcos?Rumor has it there are a few of them down there. Oh I forgot, they carry AK47s, not menus and serving trays! “Tierra y Libertad,Cabrones!!”
Only if we let them. This is outrageous! It is part and part of the destruction of the Costa Alegre environment to give way to urbanizing
my beloved tenacatita, red rock...my dear friends, we have all
lost so much...i am terribly sorry and saddened by your loss,
our loss...our precious sleepy hallow has been violated...seniora
lupe, if you see this text please contact me....all my love,
natasha
These land disputes have been flaring up since time memorial - but that technology and communication have accelerated so dramatically we must use our computers , i-phones and other media at our disposal to document these crimes. Like children when being blatantly caught doing something bad no gun can shield them from a mother' reproach . We must stand with our mothers and sisters and take back the night! Thank you for reporting
Great write up, thanks! Sad news, I knew this day was coming from the first time I saw the place. I will pass this story along.
im from rebalsito and they say that the corporation of villalobos is offer in to buy the houses from everyone in there because he wants to build a golf court in the rebalsito he is trying to get rid of everyone from there so the rebalsito would desapear thats what evil people does he is been trying to take the beach from over 25 years aready so he is mad now so he is trying to take away our own town.
I've heard the same rumors, Carlos. It's terrible to think about.