This Sporting Life

Talking about sports. Thinking about other stuff.

Wayne Norman

Wayne Norman
Bio
I teach in the Kenan Institute for Ethics and the Philosophy department at Duke University, and host the sport-and-philosophy blog, www.ThisSportingLife.net

MY RECENT POSTS

Wayne Norman's Links

Salon.com
SEPTEMBER 4, 2010 11:43PM

"Why no gatherer-sports?"

There's an old adage one hears in business schools to describe managers with a limited range of management skills (and presumably limited career prospects): if the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail.

And if the only two tools you have are a hammer

Read full post »

It's been a terrific World Cup so far. We all have to keep our fingers crossed for the semi-finals and the finals being as intriguing as the quarters, because our individual and collective memories of the overall quality of any given World Cup lean heavily on the quality of those

Read full post »

In the previous post I began with the intention of quickly introducing a link my colleague David Wong sent me to a fun article in Slate called "The Underdog Effect: why do we love a loser?" But before I could think about why some of us cheer for underdogs, I couldn't help/

Read full post »

An uncharitable, but not wholly inaccurate, line on This Sporting Life is that it's all about how to be a sports snob while still being a genuine sports fan. Of course, nobody wants to admit they're a snob. ("Connoisseur" is so much more urbane.) If you're into the themes of/

Read full post »

I'm obviously making this up as I go along; but if you've read Why is hockey analysis (almost) always so lame? Part 1 and Part 2, thanks for bearing with me. So far I have talked mostly about the ways in which hockey analysis (on TV, in the daily press) is so frust/

Read full post »

I don't remember a world without instant replay; although I was born into such a world. After clever but misbegotten attempts to use instant replay from the mid-1950s on, it is generally conceded that the first "modern" use -- and not yet slow-motion -- was in the broadcast of the

Read full post »

My friend Andrew Potter (author of the sizzling new book The Authenticity Hoaxtweeted a link on Friday [when I began writing this post] to a compelling contrast between the two biggest stars in the world of ice hockey, the Russian Alexander Ovechkin and the Canadian Sydney/

Read full post »

[Warning: What follows is an overly long post, even by the standards of this rambling blog. It is summarized over the last 3 paragraphs or so.]

At some point during the month-long March Madness gabfest on sports talk-radio Mike Greenberg (on ESPN’s “Mike and Mike in the Morning&rdqu

Read full post »

3.7 million people watched live coverage of the NFL draft this past weekend. And that figure surely doesn't include my father, since he was watching in Mexico. My dad never really stops following the NFL during the calendar year. The official end of the season with the Super Bowl just

Read full post »

In the last post I sketched out some of the reasons why Tiger fans (and some Tiger haters) like golf. And by "like" in sports I don't mean merely "enjoy" it or have a "revealed preference" for it. A true sports aficionado likes sports in the way an art-lover or

Read full post »
APRIL 11, 2010 11:09PM

What can we learn from Tiger?

Tiger Woods could be the poster child for This Sporting Life. When I began this blog I identified four broad areas of interest for me at intersection of sports-philosophy-sociology. Thinking about sports can tell us a lot aboutpunditry, institutional design and ethics (or sportsm

Read full post »

Move over Gonzaga, Villanova, George Mason, and the Western Texas Miners. There's a new Cinderella in town. Take that, Goliath: there's a new David. Butler's unlikely run all the way to the National Championship last night was like cotton-candy-for-breakfast in the sports media this morning.

Many in

Read full post »

Real NFL fans should like the new overtime rule -- especially once it gets applied to the regular season -- for the same reason that most of the real NFL coaches hate it. It holds out the promise of more high drama of the kind the NFL does best: where the

Read full post »

On Tuesday the owners of the NFL franchises agreed to change to the rules for how to deal with playoff games that end in a tie after "regulation" time. (On average, about one of the 11 games each post-season is tied after 60 minutes.)

The old rule was simple: a

Read full post »

We are rightly suspicious of arguments that justify institutional arrangements that promise to be “separate but equal.” These three conjoined words have had a unique ring in American culture ever since the landmark unanimous decision by the Supreme Court in the Brown v. Board of EducRead full post »

MARCH 18, 2010 10:19AM

How do women’s sports measure up?

You’d hardly know it watching ESPN commentators these days, but there are actually two NCAA D1 college basketball championships going on now: one for men, and one for women. (To ESPN's credit, they do pay to broadcast the women's Tournament; even if they don't give over much of their/Read full post »

In the previous post I suggested that a 65-team tournament could be justified not because it was more likely than a more exclusive tournament to crown a worthy champion, but because it helped the NCAA meet a number of its reasonable objectives – which include providing a great experience f

Read full post »
I am willing to defend the NCAA’s current system for selecting the 65 teams in the national championship Tournament. But first a confession. I am also willing to admit that I know very little about basketball. I guess I know as much as most casual fans: I can follow the ball…

Read full post »

There’s a 24-hr sports cycle in America, with several sports networks available on my cable menu any time of the day or night. ESPN alone gives me at least six, not including their virtual on-demand channels on the web. And yet most of the time no sporting matches are being played…

Read full post »

Question on SportsCenter today: “He has 6 national titles, what are your thoughts on what Hall-of-Famer Gino Auriemma has done with this program?” Bob Knight: “I’ve said in the past, that if I were an athletic director looking for a basketball coach — I don’t care…

Read full post »

You have to wonder what the ancient Greeks talked about after their Olympic games finished. (I mean, we know what the modern Greeks talked about, or should have talked about, after their Olympics: how the hell are we ever going to pay for this?! Does anybody here have any connections at… Read full post »

MARCH 2, 2010 10:00AM

Who Lost the Vancouver Olympics?

The Wall Street Journal may not have won any journalism medals for its failure to foretell which financial institutions on its eponymous street would crumble first. But they have spared us the leg work necessary to figure out which countries did the worst at the Olympics.

They have handed out lead,… Read full post »

MARCH 1, 2010 8:14AM

Who Won the Vancouver Olympics?

I suppose the official answer to this question is, “The World,” which according to the IOC mission is supposed to be made “peaceful and better” by “educating youth through sport practised in accordance with Olympism and its values.”

But of course anybody who asks… Read full post »

FEBRUARY 27, 2010 9:53PM

Chess on Ice; Chess Board on Pants

There’s an irresistible cliché for broadcasters of many sports: the “chess match.” Often an announcer is simply pointing out that there’s a tight back-and-forth battle going on. But to make sense of the metaphor there has to be some strategic rationality, where player A tries… Read full post »

FEBRUARY 26, 2010 9:08AM

How Good is Women’s Hockey?

Pretty good, that’s how good. The gold-medal game, like all of the games I can remember between the only two consistently-elite women’s teams — Canada and the USA — was certainly a thrill from start to finish.

But when we ask, “how good is it?” we usually mean, … Read full post »