Heidi Herron

Heidi Herron
Location
Wisconsin, USA
Birthday
October 31
Bio
I used to write about random things on OS, the first place I ever wrote publicly. But the political unrest that began in Wisconsin early in 2011, consumed me. My posts here are now all things Wisconsin either through documentational personal posts of the continuing struggle (which only appear on Open Salon) or through cross posts first published on WIvoices.org. I founded that organization in order to feature verbatim interviews with other Wisconsinites. These primary documents bear witness to the times that we live in and return the power to the people - where it belongs. WIvoices.org.

Editor’s Pick
MAY 27, 2011 12:28AM

WI Voices: Woman may be Forced into Nursing Home

Rate: 18 Flag
Tami Webber
  

 

Tami Weber has lived in Wisconsin’s Senate District 10 her entire life.  Now in her forties, she grew up in the late Senator Gaylord Nelson’s village – Clear Lake.  Tami now lives in a modest apartment in River Falls.  She told me that due to Walker’s impending budgetary cuts, supported by Senator Harsdorf, she may soon find herself living in a nursing home.  You see, Tami is quadriplegic.  And the Walker/Harsdorf policy is eroding the structure upon which Tami’s life is based. 

 Here’s her story.

———————–

Have you had a chance to travel much?

 As kids we did the Glacier thing, Mt. Rushmore thing…the last 20 years I’ve gone to Vegas multiple times.  I’m not a gambler, plus I have no money, but the people watching is phenomenal.  I could just sit on a bench all day, watch people and chuckle.  I also like to sit by the pool with my sister-in-laws and friends.

A little history, is that I have a rare metabolic neuromuscular disorder that stems from an error in my DNA which leaves me obese and functionally a quadriplegic.  When I was in high school I was in some sports and extremely active in many organizations.  By the time I was 21 I had my first wheelchair.  For the most part, I try to have a positive outlook because people don’t want to be around those that are crabby…and having a pity party serves no purpose…and that’s not who I am. 

With that said, there are days that I get real down and look around and I want what everyone else wants, you know – kids, family and career.  I have my bachelor’s degree and started my masters.  I think my ultimate dream job was press secretary for some Governor or Senator…public speaking was really my forte.  I do a lot of advocacy work…try to bring awareness to anything from how to treat people with disabilities to how things could be improved in the community for those who are disabled. 

One of the things I like to do is try to teach those around me.  As an example, I like to go to ShopKo and it is really interesting…kids are so fascinated with my power wheelchair. They like the wheels and they are also wondering “why can’t she walk”?  Kids could care less, and so I start talking to them.  But a lot of the times it is the parents who are telling their kids “don’t stare” or  “don’t look”.   And I say “Oh its ok” and I try to educate both the parents and the children about disabilities.

What exactly is going on in your world right now?

There are many ideas and some rumors floating around regarding portions of Medicaid.   Walker is trying to freeze, or else limit funding, for the “Specialized Transportation Program.”  At best, this will make transportation significantly difficult.  To get to my medical appointments at Mayo [Clinic in Rochester, MN] I need to use a specialized transportation company [Handi-Lift].  First of all, they [Walker and supporters] forget about NW Wisconsin.  The [Handi-Lift] company gets paid for the initial pick-up and by the mile.  If the funding is frozen and gas is high, companies will have to start billing more. 

Walker is also trying to limit the transportation companies from crossing state lines.  If I couldn’t go to Mayo, I would have to go to Marshfield or Madison. Now, door-to-door to the Mayo Clinic is 70 miles.  Marshfield is 3 hours from here, Madison is 3 ½ hours. 

So instead of going to Mayo, you’d have a 7 or 8 hour trip in the van, not counting the extra money spent for personal care workers.  Not only does that seem to be a complete inconvenience for you – but also an ineffective cost scenario because of the number of miles the taxpayers would have to pay in gas alone.

 Exactly.  And not to mention that I have personal care workers that instead of getting me in the van by 7:30 or 8:00 in the morning, I’d have to be in the van by 5:00.  So let’s talk about tax payer money.  If you start adding more co-pays and start decreasing the medical benefits, clinic visits may go down, but ER visits will shoot through the roof.  The other people in the community will suddenly have to start paying more to eat those costs of ER visits.

[Tami’s monthly income of $777/month from Social Security is quickly consumed by rent, utilities, food, medical co-pays, etc.]

What would it mean to you if all of these policies went through that Walker is pushing and supported by Senator Harsdorf?

 If Walker’s budget repair bill goes through I most definitely see myself in a nursing home within two years.  If you cut my general healthcare (Medicaid), funding to my personal care workers, and my transportation – what choice do I have?  Then add Congressman Paul Ryan’s purposed cuts to my other insurer, Medicare….a nursing home is most definitely going to be my only option.

I’m 44-years-old.  I’m college educated…a completely cognitive individual.  Is a nursing home really the appropriate place for me?  Not too long ago the big push was to keep people in their homes.  This isn’t 1950.  They let us out of institutions for a reason.  And as I’d like to say, “You let us out – you can’t push us back in.” Contrary to what Mr. Walker would like to do to us; this is 2011 darn it, and we have just as much right to live where WE want!  People should be able to live among their peers.

[Tami is one of 61,000 of Wisconsinites that needs Medicaid to remain in the community of choice rather than an institution.  She asserts that she is less expensive for the tax payer in her own home.  She tells me that her personal care workers earn $12/hour and are on hand for her 11 hours/day.  Using those figures quick math puts the current cost for tax payers at a little over $48,000/year for Tami.  In comparison, according to Special State Report From Families, nursing homes in Wisconsin average $81,400/year.]

How does Walker’s phrase “Wisconsin – Open for Business” make you feel?

 Yeah – if you have a lot of money – come off it…let’s keep taking things away from the most vulnerable…let’s put people in institutions where they can’t be seen.  He wants to decimate the middle and lower class…absolutely decimate it. 

I have fought so hard to stay in my home and keep good personal care workers who respect me.  It’s not easy to have people come in and bath you and dress you, feed you.  And sometimes it can be difficult because I feel like I have a revolving door of workers.  But, it is still a choice for me and better than being in a nursing home.  If I want to go for a walk in the park – I can go.  All of my nieces’ and nephews’ birthday parties and family holidays are here.  Would I still be able to do all of that if I were in a nursing home?

And, I know what I’m talking about.  I’ve been in a nursing home – for a month when I was 27 and recovering from major surgery, I was there for 4 weeks.  It is not a place for a younger person who is fully cognitive.  You start getting up at 5:00 a.m. because the aides have so many people to get up that they have to do that.  The aides, bless their hearts, do the best they can.  Then after breakfast the CNAs lay everyone down for a nap.  Suddenly, they thought that I needed a nap, too.  Then, they get everybody up for lunch.  Then back down for a nap.  Absolutely no privacy or dignity–just the nature of institutional life.

Now, I have freedom to walk out that door whenever I want to.  Once in awhile I like to have some friends over – say a Friday night and we play board games or watch movies…I might have a couple of beers, I might have a couple of wine coolers.  On a warm summer evening I like to sip on brandy slush and watch a ball game.  I’m a sports fanatic. In a nursing home all of your clothes are written on too – so they know who it belongs to.  I am picky about some of my clothes.  Should we label all of your clothes Governor? Or maybe we should have his meals unseasoned and “soft” just for starters.

Sound bites coming from the Walker/Harsdorf camp suggest that folks have to “demonstrate an ability to adapt.”

 How much more adapting are we suppose to do?  How much more adapting?  Our whole life is about adapting.  Our whole life.  I can tell you right here and right now, that my health would get worse, faster, because I would have no purpose and no will to live. How would you like your basic dignity taken away?

 What is your sense of Senator Harsdorf who was just recalled?

 (Pause) Do you have 8 days?

(Laughing) Have you ever met her?

 Ah, it is funny that you should ask that.  Sheila and I are personal friends.  Sheila has been in my home numerous numerous times.  We’ve made dinner together, gone on walks together!  She has said, “You are such an inspiration” or “I’m so proud of you.”

I take this whole thing like a slap in the face.  And not that I expect her to change her vote solely because she knows me, but do I think that she gave one second thought to me?  Not at all.  I’ve given her numbers on how keeping me in my home is cheaper.  And it is cheaper.  I’m on a program called “SDS” (Self Determined Support) which means I get to decide who I hire and who I fire.  I get to decide a lot of my life instead of having a county social worker or home health nurse do that – which also saves a lot of money.  I fail to see why I should not have all of the same choices as to where I live. There is no reason that I shouldn’t have say in my life – absolutely none.  Somehow I don’t think that she gave one second thought to me.  I’ve tried to call her and she has not returned one phone call of mine.  I completely understand that Senator Harsdorf is incredibly busy, but she’s got to know how I feel about this. 

——————————————–

When the policies of Walker/Harsdorf call for a shared sacrifice, I can’t help but wonder how much one human can give.  Tami is a happy, productive member of society.  If the impending cuts to her medical care, personal care workers, and transportation are enacted – moving into a nursing home would be the only way she could have her basic needs met.  Then, her human need for self-determination and choice will seem a luxury.  These shortsighted and ineffective policies not only seem bad for the tax payer, but also exact a human toll which cannot be quantified.  So, once again Tami asks, “Is a nursing home really the appropriate place for me?”

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
A couple of things:

1. Keep posting these stories. These are voices that absolutely must be heard.

2. You've got my utmost respect and support, Heidi. For a multitude of reasons, not the least of which is ceaselessly putting the word out there.

3. Additional kudos and welcome to you, as yourself, with your name, writing loud and proud.

All around . . . blessings, friend . . . namaste . . .
What Owl said, Heidi. Your interviews make us know what the stakes are and make clear how utterly wrongheaded--okay 'bloody-minded" is nearer the mark--Walker's vision of how he wants Wisconsin to be. I guess Alan Grayson really called it on the Republicans "don't get sick, but if you do, die silently and swiftly so we don't have to help you." Do they have a single atom of human decency LEFT???? No matter how mad I get, it's impossible to keep up.

It makes absolutely no sense, financially or emotionally to force Tami to give up what independence, privacy and dignity she has. She definitely doesn't belong in a nursing home.

As for Harsdorf--good grief, she's met this woman and, knowing how Tami and no doubt many others would get screwed by this budget, she's still going to do it? No wonder she's too ashamed to return Tami's calls! I'm not even a Wisconsinite and I've definitely hadanuffa Harsdorf!

rated
Owl and Shiral - thanks so much, Tami will be reading these today and this will absolutely encourage her and empower her knowing that her voice - speaking for other developmentally disabled folks too - is being heard loud and clear.

On a personal note - thanks to you both for your stand in this fight for WI and for our county. You both are dear to my heart.

Today, we are wearing our red solidarity shirts and will continue canvassing our city for our candidate - Shelly Moore. Right now, I'm off to breakfast with my son at his school.

OS - Thank -you. I feel blessed to be part of this community of voices.
I got my shirt! And I'll wear it for Tami, and for all of Wisconsin. Not that most Californians will have a clue what it stands for.
But I will try to educate them.
I am a former caregiver of a spinal injury quadriplegic. Lani would have died within 3 months in a nursing home. Fortunately for her she was fully--and fairly lucratively--employed, and could get along without the state's help. At least when I knew her. Good thing. She lives in Florida. Good luck to Tami, and thanks again for keeping us informed!!
i keep reading your posts; i am floored by the pending doom (not only to be inflicted on Tami Weber and those reliant on social services) but for those who think political cost cutting won't eventually render their lives intolerable or inhumane.
your writing on the Wisconsin Insanity Experiment ( sorry for the pun, but Walker is insane and his politics a disgusting referendum on power elites eschewing common sense and practicality).
Thank you for posting this. You are indeed and advocate for the poor and disenfranchised. With people such as yourself and your family and friends, these people will be voted out of office. I can feel the mood shifting in this country. Fox in losing viewers in droves. Beck, gone, thank God, but others need to go to. They made a grave mistake taking on the new third rail, Medicare, and trying to dismantle it. It going to look good seeing them walking down of the steps of state and federal buildings with their bags packed!
I'm thankful you have the grace and fortitude to bring the "faces" of Tami, Frank, and others to the forefront. These are some of the special interests who should receive consideration from our politicians.

Unfortunately, it often seems as though the other special interests win political favor from the statehouse and the support of so many uninformed, scared citizens.

I've been talking with well educated, seemingly intelligent, and otherwise humane people who embrace the cost cutting maneuvers of the Republicans. This has a chilling effect on me. I have to wonder what it will take to move America back to a sentient, humane nation.

Our politicians should be examining ways to increase revenue and to use that extra revenue to help those in need. Until they commit to this kind of creative thinking, I'm afraid those who need the most help will fall by the wayside.
Making the world safe for billionaires' tax breaks, one quadriplegic at a time.
Thanks for posting. Another example of how human beings are the last on the list of Walker's priorities. Wisconsin is the front line. Their fight is our fight. They must win out. We must support them.
This is a great reflection on the ongoing policies of the Rethugs Heidi. It ain't about the people involved at all.
It is all about money and greed...and that is a sad fact for us all.
Tami too.
You know I'm such a fan of your WI reporting, and the Voices series is even more touching in some ways. If Tami does read this, please know that we do hear you and many of us will do whatever it takes to keep fighting the good fight -- as you already do. I genuinely cannot "grok" the greedy heartless liars that occupy too many government seats -- it boggles the mind.
Stories like this really bring it home - the cost of the callousness and stupidity of arrogant politicians and their wealthy cronies. I don't know how you face all of this on a daily basis Heidi, it would sink me into despair. But I thank you for making me see it.
Thanks for listening to the voices in WI everybody. I don't sink into depression, because this empowers me and everyone else when we are heard. I'm action oriented. If get sad or angry, I hit the canvassing maps, interview someone else, or drop off yard signs.

We will not lose - we win for standing up for what is right, regardless of the outcome.
Heidi, thank you for writing this. It floods me with a myriad of thoughts and emotions. I need to think about this and come back to re-read your article. I just wanted to say 'kudos - this is exceptional work'.
Thank you for putting a personal touch on the ridiculous changes from the Gov of Wisconsin. This is important for everyone to know. You are doing important work.
I love old new lefty--"making the world safe for billionaire tax breaks, one quadriplegic at the time" will be my new political motto.

Tami, I wish there was something I could do to help you.

My wonderful brother-in-law has Lou Gehrig's disease. I have such a sense of helplessness as I watch this once vital, 6' 4", muscular athlete become more and more disabled. He and my sister are in the "what will insurance and Medicare pay for?" nightmare every day. His care is incredibly expensive.

Families should not go bankrupt when a family member becomes ill in the richest country the world has ever seen. It is an abomination.
We need more stories like this one, not just online but in the traditional media. In the meantime, bravo for posting this. Rated.

Cutting personal care services for the disabled in favor of institutionalization is false economy. Institutional care is far more costly. Evidently though, nursing homes have a much more powerful lobby than personal care firms do.

I believe that nursing homes ultimately need to go the way of alms houses and orphanages.
Not only is this cruel, it makes no sense. These fiscal conservatives are about anything except saving money. Either they want to funnel money to private business or they simply have no idea of the consequences of their policies. I hope this likable women doesn't end up in the nursing home she dreads.
The state of WI has almost 5.7 million people. You don't make policy for over 5 million people based on what might happen to one here and one there. If fact there is no way possible to make any decision that will not help some and hurt others. You will always be able to find someone who is being hurt by government.

The good of the many out weights the good of the few.
catnlion - "If fact there is no way possible to make any decision that will not help some and hurt others."

First of all, if you read the entire passage Tami is representative of a group of tens of thousands in our state, who represents millions in the country. This is a common problem, not an isolated one.

Even if it were, it is a proven that it is cheaper for the tax payer, and better for Tami, to allow her to stay in her home. Now, if you view corporations as having the same human rights as an actual human being, then you may have a point. But, corporations don't live or die based upon on the tax code. People do. Your callousness reeks of apathy. Not caring makes life much easier.
What can I do to help?
why are they giving more money to those that have the most, and then taking more from those that have the least?

there is no guarantee that they will provide jobs from tax cuts; it should be mandatory
Great so you want to help Tami. Who wouldn't? There are people with problems all over. So do you want to help everyone? How are you going to do that? The fact is you can't. Every rule or law is going to hurt someone. What if you say the cut off on something is 60? What do you say to some one who is 59.999? Do you say you're close enough or do you say you are not 60?


Your not understanding that you can't make a law that doesn't help some and hurt others is proven by your statements about corporate taxes. No corportation pays taxes. You pay the taxes and the corporation only handles the money.

The government says corportation give me a dollar in taxes, and the corporation says customer give me another dollar.